Quote:
Originally Posted by RM Clarinet
Well, Congrats
Part 1
1. Nice begening.
2. Scherzo, "Playfully, Fun...Literally a "joke" " it did not seem like that so far.
Part 2
1. I like the Chalumeu sound of the clarinet
2. I like this part a lot
3. not much of a march, but a nocturne yes
Part 3
1. Entry is good no clarinet...why?
all together
It does not match. unless it stopped like Gregorious. other wise nice song.
_____________________
|
I'm afraid I don't understand your comment regarding the scherzo. (A complete sentence would actually be helpful in understanding here)
Are you saying that my scherzo is not "joke-ish" in character?
If so, I'd recommend you listen to the scherzo of Schostakowitch's 10th symphony. What defines a scherzo is the form, not the character.
nor your comment about part 2, regarding the "not much of a march".
why is there no clarinet for the entry of the Arioso? because I figured the poor clarinetist deserved a brief break.
What "does not match"?
may I comment on your comments?
it's not a "song". it's a "piece of music". a "song" has lyrics. just thought I'd mention that.