View Single Post
  #17 (permalink)  
Old Jun 19 2007, 8:57 AM
manossg manossg is offline

manossg's Avatar

Gone semi-pro
Group: Members
Joined: 25-February 07
Posts: 974
Member Number: 2246
Sure, let's give it another shot.

Gave it a second (& third listen). At least for the first and third part.

My initial post still stands, unchallenged, at least aurally. Especially for the first part, I have a stronger feeling that the music is going around in circles, not actually leading anywhere but chasing its tail. It would be great if it had some direction, but, with disappointment, I have to re-state my opinion that it does not.

Nikola, I won't invest any more of my time in this work (except for the second part), looking for more insights, at least not without a score. Maybe that made the difference for you, but I still don't have one at my disposal.

I agree that sometimes (sometimes? All the time!), music can be re-approached and felt differently than the initial listen, but this isn't the case, unfortunately.

The cello sonata stands unrivaled (for me). And it is beautiful, score or no score.

And I am sorry if I sound harsh, but I don't like to mince words, either.
__________________
Audio ergo sum
'You haven't cried enough tears in your life to play this music' - Mstislav Rostropovich

Posts:Adagio 'for Eva' for Piano Trio Recording!!!!
Groundwork for war (Zonnymi) trailer (w/recording) The complete work coming soon!
Chansons Mélancoliques One chanson posted thus far.
Currently working on;
Apostasis (for piano quintet and soprano in 3 movements) - Recording...
Dwmatia (for solo viola, single movement) - Halfway through!
Reply With Quote