All these are just opinions and I don't think even time can tell who is right or who is wrong.
It's just personal taste, and I'd be happy if I changed my opinion after studying the score or hearing the live performance, none of which are available at the moment.
It is nice talking with people that don't take negative feedback defensively.
The not-so-young part of YC, mostly...
My friend QC, Nikolas' suggestion of a video of the premiere is excellent.
