Quote:
Originally Posted by Qccowboy
so, taste. personal. nothing more. unless one can actually find "errors" in a score that can justify a more objective criticism.
|
Exactly that! And taste is completely personal! sure at some points it is SO obvious that is lacking myriads of stuff and ideas (Saul and Paul for example, who denied pretty much the existance of 200 years of advancement in music), but sure taste is personal, even in those extgreme cases! Anyone can like and dislike.
Another thing that has been brought to my mind is exactly the term "reviews" here.
It is not reviews that should be taken hugely into account... Of course I, personally, have a bad habbit of taking everything into account, and holding it, 'till I rot inside in a specific work, and usually I do change some stuff (except on things already performed, or in works that I've been through that process already).
but it is getting off topic, no? Michel, you are a mod, you can move posts around. If you feel this is completely off topic, go ahead. no problem here
