|
Alright, I came in after the answer was given but, here here are the reasons I believe it was obvious that No. 1 was composed by a machine:
1) When I opened the midi up in SongWriter, the instrument was "New-Gesture" which instantly struck me as odd. Bach-2 had "Instrument 1-4" on it. Anyway, that's not very conclusive proof.
2) Bach-1 was written so... industrially. There were these really strong hits on 1 and 3 and there seemed to be no real, intuitive division of sections. The constant undying, unending rhythm really got on my nerves, whereas Bach-2 was more fluid and did have intuitive divisions (even if there were a freaking lot of them).
Anyway, I voted for Bach-1 before I even read the discussion, and I was about 75% sure.
__________________
"My mom had a uterus... I lived in it."
|