View Single Post
  #221 (permalink)  
Old Mar 11 2008, 10:40 PM
Magna Carta Magna Carta is offline

Magna Carta's Avatar

Funny, right?
Group: Members
Joined: 17-July 06
Posts: 265
Member Number: 1120
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kije of Prokofiev View Post
I despise vivaldi for the same reason I hate Danzi and Hummel-multiple concerti and chamber music for the bassoon that all sound EXACTLY THE SAME
You know, I never really understood this comment about Vivaldi. Isn't it rather normal for a composer to sound the same throughout all his works?

Also, for those who do criticise Vivaldi for being repetitive, I urge you to listen to some of his sacred works (besides the famous Gloria, RV 589) - they are, if anything, the most original works of his conception.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kije of Prokofiev View Post
But on a lighter note, anyone else a fan of Edward Elgar?
I hate Elgar for the same reason I hate Mahler - they are composers of dreadful music that makes me want to pull my eyes out of their sockets.

I have a few new adds to my fav. composer list:
  • Veracini
  • Gasparini
  • Lully
  • Holst
  • Shostakovich (<3 Symphony N° 10)
__________________
Latest Work: Concerto in F major for strings and continuo
If I take time to critique a piece of yours, I would greatly appreciate it if you took the time to critique mine.
Reply With Quote