How about this in replacement for my own iffy?
It could also be :-/ or :-\ or just :/ or :\
Another...
:patty: ? Hey, we have a santa one, we should have others too.
*updates own emotes page*
J4's Collection of Emoticons
*ground shakes*
P.S. I think our list of smilies needs to be reorganised to accommodate the new additions in a more logical manner. They are kinda strewn about in random order, methinks.