View Single Post
  #20 (permalink)  
Old Apr 21 2008, 2:50 PM
DOFTS DOFTS is offline

DOFTS's Avatar

A Wrecked Fool
Group:
Joined: 27-February 08
Posts: 769
Member Number: 4347
I understand why they choose not to listen to it. I don't agree why they decided to make a little rant about it though.

This is the way I see it:

If he really wanted to compose serious music, he would have taken time to learn about the instruments. Writing nonchalant and expecting people here to listen to it on a purely musical level is not going to happen. It's the nature of this site. There are many aspects to writing music, and one of them is knowing how to use your instruments properly. While I listen to his piece (before I read his reviews), I knew he had no idea how to use ANY of his instruments. He would, undoubtedly, improve if he knew how to his tools to their potential.

I can agree that the rant presented by the first two reviewers was lame and unneeded, but nevertheless they are correct. I just wish they would have also commented on other aspects too.

I know he was mostly experimenting with his program, but it doesn't justify sloppy habits. He obviously thought he made something worth listening to, or he wouldn't have posted it. If he thought otherwise, he purposely wasted our time.
__________________
Kasner, E. and Newman, J.
Mathematics is the science which uses easy words for hard ideas.

Hilbert, David (1862-1943)
Mathematics knows no races or geographic boundaries; for mathematics,the cultural world is one country.

http://comphq.informe.com/index.php
Reply With Quote