Thread: Annie's Rose
View Single Post
  #4 (permalink)  
Old Apr 22 2008, 10:14 PM
Will Kirk Will Kirk is offline

Will Kirk's Avatar

2 Kitties in 2 Cups
Group: Members
Joined: 1-June 06
Posts: 3,288
Member Number: 901
Quote:
Originally Posted by maaton View Post
love is a very personal matter, it is very tough to express it musically without being cliche. Personally, I think I would never compose about love exactly for the above reason, cause usually when I lie in bed with my girlfriend caressing her it sounds just like your piece in my head (rather harp than guitar but that's not the point). I'm not so sure it's worth recording though. It lasts for the moment, never more. I'm not saying that there are no non-cliche love songs because there are hundreds of them but it's a very tricky area. In your case you stand for something very broad, well documented and accepted general "love mood" especially on the most common instrument, the guitar. So my question would be. Why do we feel this is love sonically? Isn't it because this is what we immediately associate with it? Sorrow and love. Basic feelings. Very easy to express yet almost impossible to do it in an interesting way. and I'm not so sure feelings are that simple nowadays. I'm almost never in a definite mood. it's always mixed. like always. this is why i don't believe in this piece although I perfectly know what it tries to recall. You made a very nice recording on a very mellow sounding instrument very pure and everything yet you remain on an uninteresting territory. What's interesting to me? Something I don't really know but charms me. Something unpredictable yet perfectly understandable. This piece I know 100%. I can hear it every night in my head. And maybe 9 people out of 10 would associate this piece with love. So in this sense congratulations! It's an another love song... a decent one... you are a good player as well! i can hear you are intimate with your instrument. that's a good thing.
Thanks for listening and I appreciate the comment

Although, I don't want to sound stuck up, but that was extremely wordy, you could have easily said "this piece really makes me think of love, I think that's a good thing"

I'm not trying to nitpick, but not every other person might want to read a long message with a short meaning I'm not trying to tear you down, just trying to help

Thanks again
__________________
Currently Listening to: Whatever I feel like... and Meshuggah

www.soundclick.com/williamdanielkirkland
my soundclick channel ^^^

Another year older, another year wiser...
Reply With Quote