Hehe, mabye that is your point of view and i accept that, my question was at the start of the thread? is this art? and you say yes, i say no
im sure the man is a good composer, but that 4,33 piece is not composition, and i dont think this way " woow what a genious he turned a concerto in to a 4,33 silence" great idea, i think this way, "what the hell is he doing? inviting to a concerto and have not written a note? this is not music and sure not composition, and they call it a piece, its not" just wanted to dicuss with you what you mean about that piece, he have other pieces like that too, one for piano, one note only " listen to the soundwaves".
All i say to do that "write music" without one single note or any sound, or one note and imagine the rest of the music, listen to the crowd "sneez" i dont see any music in that.
But you well know my opinoin, i wanted to know yours, but the thing that is bothering me is you allways need to insult me, i dont insult you. Discuss with the proper arguments and without insulting the other part, if you say? i dont like baroque, i dont like classical music i like Cage, and i dont consider the old music as art anymore, well i say i dont, but id never call you narrowminded stupid etc.