View Single Post
  #150 (permalink)  
Old May 28 2008, 7:13 PM
Jamie Whitmarsh Jamie Whitmarsh is offline

Jamie Whitmarsh's Avatar

Composer
Group: Members
Joined: 14-January 06
Posts: 344
Member Number: 464
It seems to me that possibly we are saying similar things, but calling them by different names. I see music as a very ethereal thing, and I agree that you should write what you want within reason. I don't think you should necessarily allow others to tell you what to write (unless that's your job, in which case it is somewhat unavoidable sometimes) but I think you should be able to improve and regulate yourself (one of the reasons I don't think one should write for orchestra until one has a decent grasp on the basics.) I don't correlate 'good' music with music that I like. I like a lot of stuff and I recognize that it's not good music. I like it for whatever reasons. I am not sure about defining what good music is; it has some intangible quality that makes it good.

EDIT - This post was directed to SSC. Gardener's post popped up while I was typing this.
Reply With Quote