Quote:
Originally Posted by flint-wwrr
Not to split hairs, but I treat "singers" and "vocalists" very differently.
Vocalists are musicians whose instrument is voice. Vocalists are trained musicians, read music, and are generally musically knowledgeable. Vocalists are usually prepared, learn their music outside of rehearsal, and act professionally.
Singers are trained dogs. Singers almost can never read music, they learn by rote memorization, and generally take up the bulk of space in most choirs and musical productions. Singers learn nothing outside of rehearsal - they can't read music! Singers are never prepared, and reliance on rote memorization means that they go through little material, as they are continually having to re-hash and re-learn material they've forgotten.
I very rarely work choose to work with Singers.
Arooooo!
|
That's a really, REALLY weird division. For me singer is someone who... well, sings.
There are better singers than others, and methods may vary. But uh, the only difference I can probably make is a solo singer and a choir singer. That's mostly in technique and repertoire. Some singers work in choirs, some rather do solo careers.
I don't really know where you got your grudge, but well. Just weird that's all.