View Single Post
  #3 (permalink)  
Old Jun 16 2008, 12:34 PM
david ckwee david ckwee is offline

david ckwee's Avatar

bureaucratic composer
Group: Members
Joined: 30-November 07
Posts: 138
Member Number: 3852
Quote:
Originally Posted by Terve View Post
Lol.

Wow, there were some really pleasing moments in this. I disagree that you are not talented, you obviously have a very imaginitive ear, and admirable self-control to stick to your own agenda of self-improvement. The melodies are especially pleasing (especially the one from b.43), and yes, you've certainly departed from I-IV-V - your harmonic ideas and imagination are really interesting and engaging. I love the counterplay between the violin and piano RH, it's very pleasing. The waltzy motif in the LH is stylistic but occasionally gets a bit monotonous - though the interesting chords goes some way to redeem this, like in the final four bars - such that when b.26 comes, there's a tangible sense of relief, lol. (For me anyway). Perhaps a bit more variation of this sort would retain interest more - especially between the two main themes?

But overall I though this was lovely, well done.

(PS. are you sure you can't put it in .pdf? If it's your .pdf writer try CutePDF. They are meant to be able to convert any printable document. Forgive me if you know this already, but there isn't any 'exporting' involved, you just tell it to print and select your .pdf writer from the list of printers).


Hey terve;
Thanks for taking your time to review my piece. I very much appreciate that! Also, thanks for your compliments! It made me a little warm inside.

Yes, thanks alot, I just did that. Thankfully I googled it. Nah I did'nt know that, thanks for telling!


Ill take your comments and work on them! Thanks really!
__________________
Silence is golden. Dissonance is Silver. Resolved dissonance is priceless.
Criticism, constructive ones, will only lead to the embetterment of one's standards.
Reply With Quote