View Single Post
  #5 (permalink)  
Old Jun 17 2008, 11:41 AM
david ckwee david ckwee is offline

david ckwee's Avatar

bureaucratic composer
Group: Members
Joined: 30-November 07
Posts: 136
Member Number: 3852
Hey Seraphim,

Firstly, thanks for your review! I really appreciated that.

-The tempo it is written at was actually faster when I first heard it in my mind yeah. I think it should be acceptable, but pray, is it too fast?

-Repetition of theme in more than one key ( errr... Im not sure whether What you meant by this, would you mind elaborating? )

-Extravagant Accompaniment ( er... again, sorry but yeah, You mind elaborating? Or rather explain, for I er don't know what youre pointing towards... )



Actually, I might be inclined to say that the tempation to "cut and paste" the accompaniment and ornate just the piano right hand was too great, but I realised that It has produced a rather sloppy work. I am sorry for that, yeah.


For the Pseudo Fugue, er... I dint intend it to be a fugue, but the problem is what, erm, did you mean by pseudo? (pardon me, my english is not strong..)




Thanks alot, once again, and I do really hope you can reply to my questions!
__________________
Silence is golden. Dissonance is Silver. Resolved dissonance is priceless.
Criticism, constructive ones, will only lead to the embetterment of one's standards.
Reply With Quote