Mike

A score isn't exactly required, but the guidelines do state that no review should be expected if there is no score, which is fair enough in my opinion.

It used to be that a score was absolutely mandatory, but that rule was changed in light of the fact that there are many legitimate reasons for people not being able to or willing to submit scores. Often, it's fear of plagiarism. In Qccowboy's case, I believe it has something to do with copyright, can't quite remember what exactly.

Still, I think it's better this way. After all, stunning works like this are what make the Major Works forum credible. And it would just be plain silly to move this work to another forum.