|
I have a scoring idea that is somewhat complex but I think is effective:
Each entry will be graded in all the 7 aforementioned categories on a scale of one to ten, making the final score for each piece out of 70. 80% (or 56 points) will be the cutoff for the semifinals, all of which will be deemed "Honorable Mentions". Each Judge will vote on their favorite three semifinalists (or "Honorable Mentions"), the best of which overall will proceed to the finals. The finalists will be put in order of best to least best by each judge, best earning two points, least best zero, and the middle one, one. The finalist with the greatest number of points will be crowned Best Choral Piece of YC. The 2nd best will be crowned Almost Best Choral Piece of YC. The 3rd best will be crowned...
...well they can just be a 'finalist'. If there is a tie, Mike (it's his site) or Nickthoven (it's his thread) will break it.
Good method of scoring? Comments?
__________________
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Marcel Proust
Every reader finds himself. The writer's work is merely a kind of optical instrument that makes it possible for the reader to discern what, without this book, he would perhaps never have seen in himself.
|
|