Quote:
|
However, that does not label such baritones as "second tenors" and I despise being labeled as such. Just as Mezzo's don't typically appreciate being labeled as "second sopranos". My range doesn't dip as low as that of a well trained bass, and doesn't reach as high as a well trained tenor.
|
OOO - Now I know how to insult you should the need arise . - - You, you... SECOND TENOR!!
- Just practicing.
.
Joking aside. Because I have never participated in one of these things before, I'm curious what the process for this type of competition is, or what Nick might have had in mind. No doubt, it will be difficult to judge apples against oranges, and your concerns and ideas deserve consideration.
One of my first thoughts off the bat would be to wait to see a good portion of the submissions before jumping to a decision on the matter. I.e., the winning entries may be very obvious to the judges and there may be no need to assign specialists. Certainly, where comments are concerned, those who are most knowledgeable in those different areas should step to the plate and put in the lions share of the work if necessary. I feel that to make this an enjoyable and/or valuable learning experience for all involved, all judges should attempt to comment to the best of thier abilities on all peices. But not knowing the judging criterion or even commenting the process at this point, it's near impossible for me to make any suggestions.
So, for the time being - I'm awaiting instructions.
Aug 19 2006, 5:17 PM
Linear Mode
