Choral Competition - Judges Discussion Thread

Have we yet decided on an appropriate method of grading? I have tallied my scores and am prepared to give you my top 3 choices. I suggest that we look into the scoring method that I have suggested where each piece is alotted points based on how many people select is as first, second, or third. This would really simplify things for our middle man/points counter so he doesn't have to bust a blood vessel in his brain figuring out percentages and so on. Any comments?

I didn't judge using grades or scores, I just went through, wrote comments and came to a conclusion on which work I thought was the most proficient. However, at Nick's request, I also provided an overall percentage score for each submission. I think he'll then tot up all of the overall percentages handed out by the judges and produce an average which will determine the winner of the competition.

Shouldn't this thread and the closed one beneath it be moved to the archive?