|
Even if it's not in the foreground all the time, you've got some very idiomatic material for the viola in there, and it's there enough to get noticed... similarly in many ways to piano concerti where the piano often accompanies the orchestra. But there are a few places where the viola isn't so effective. Maybe it's just the MIDI, but it sounds like a string crossing exercise at times.
From listening to it, I'm pretty sure I can play it without all that much difficulty, so I might attempt that and comment again afterward.
Since you mention it... it's funny why we decide to write for certain instruments. My horn concerto, which was my first composition, has a similar history. I actually started writing it in high school, with a girl that I had a crush on at the time in mind, but gave up after writing about 30 measures' worth of melody. That was my one and only early attempt at composition. Four years later, I randomly found the notes while cleaning out my room... ironically enough, I'd met another female horn player the previous day. And so I started making a serious effort at composing from that point on.
Of course, neither of them ever played the piece in full - it took more than two years from the time I continued - though both have now actually played individual movements.
__________________
Andrew Hsieh
Medical Student and Composer
View my profile
The piano quartet is COMPLETE!!!
Please note that I will not review the following without a very good reason:
1) MP3-only posts: no score + outside link = bad deal. Especially true because I'm on dialup when at home.
2) Shoutbox or PM spam: excessive shameless plugs get very annoying very fast.
3) Pieces written in a short time or with little effort: if it's not worth the composer's time and energy, then it's not worth mine either.
|