Melody #1

Here's my stab at this. Flute/Strings/Piano.

I will remove the .mp3 if you want me too, I just wanted you guys to hear the soundfonts instead of the .mid file

Ok here is my updated version. I couldn't figure out how to edit or delete my last post so it looks like i'm going to start a new one.

So many good harmonizations! mine is probably the worst....

Wolf: what do you mean, ''change the ending''? i like it!

i fixed some clutzy stuff....

PS: When will this be rated?

I could have sworn I already posted this. Guess not. I think it's pretty good. >_>

Lethan, you asked when this will be rated and i have no idea but i thought i'd just give my opinion on who's i like the most. And that would be bitterducks. great job to all, though!

So many good harmonizations! mine is probably the worst....

Wolf: what do you mean, ''change the ending''? i like it!

i fixed some clutzy stuff....

PS: When will this be rated?

Why did you make the end so happy?! I sounded sooooo cool during the first part when it was eery...

And i don't think we sohuld be rated (like 7/10), maybe the moderator should just pick one that is the best...

Why did you make the end so happy?! I sounded sooooo cool during the first part when it was eery...

And i don't think we sohuld be rated (like 7/10), maybe the moderator should just pick one that is the best...

Well, I agree with you Wolf. I think the Mods should PM people what they think needs work and advice, or we can do all do that after a certain amount of days.

Whoever wants to discuss it should be allow to, but as Wolf__88 said, try to get more into detail rather than just place a numerical score on it. Perhaps you'd also like to expand a bit on why you liked BitterDuck's entry the best, PianoGirl?

I don't think we should necessarily have to pick a "winner", but we could evaluate the strengths of each harmonization at least. Although a few of these are not harmonizations, but rather full-blown arrangements or transcriptions. With a harmonization, you should be able to say what chords you used to harmonize which parts of the melody. This might help us understand your harmonization and also give other people ideas about harmony.

For example, here are the chords I used in my harmonization (In order):

g min7, A half-dim7, g min7, F# dim7, D7, Eb maj7, F7, f# dim7, C, G

In case of confusion, in mine the harp has the chord arpeggiated in each measure, and the pizz strings have the bass note.

I am not sure how to arrange the comments yet, but I will be thinking about it (this is basically a test forum, to see if it will work out).

I encourage everyone to try to comment on each harmonization in the meantime, while you bear with me, and while I try to think of a better way to organize this particular forum. Be courteous to the others, and realize they are probably awaiting your opinions, just as much as you are awaiting theirs!