Melody #17

Okay, here's my attempt at harmonization.

I liked the piano melody so much that I left it at the forefront, just with simple accompaniment behind.

I did change the last measure to create a more finished ending.

(BTW: I loved Hihi's arrangement! Great interpretation!)

Hey Guys,

Wow! So many people have posted already Thanks for all the nice comments about my melody! I wish I could have finished with it before I posted it online, but I was too excited about doing my own version and seeing what other people thought that I decided to post it anyway - thats why the last measure was unfinished, as David pointed out.

Well, I don't think I stayed too closely within the rules , but after all it is my melody lol The later half remains relatively unchanged, the first half is pretty different though. I think I might need to chop off the end section too, seems to take away the dramatic edge. I saved it as a the original piano sonata, and also as a work for church organ and a violin sonata for a bit of contrast (without the end section). Please tell me which of the three you prefer, and if I should scrap the end section.

Really enjoyed Frantz piece (very Baroque! and loved your counter melodies - very your style!!) and Arthur's (had zest but was very short); Hihi's percussion ensemble (very Monkey Island 2 lol) and David Guinness (yours is almost exactly like mine in some parts, its scary!). Anyway, thanks again guys, and please comment on mine.

Regards
Pravin

P.S
I think its in C minor - could someone with better knowledge of theory please tell me? lol. thanks

It's indeed in C minor. I had problems transcirpting it correctly.

As for my piece, it's eventually unfinished. I'll finish it very soon!

My whole attempt to this basic stuff.
Enjoy!

hi Upstart and everybody!

i have posted a mp3 at http://www.soundclick.com/bands/song...songID=4525529 because i am lately upset with midis

by the way, all of you have made very nice versions, so congrats to you all!

Originally Posted by Dunael

Wow ! You're from NZ !... I dream to go teach there since I'm a teenage. That's really one of the most beautiful country ! I'm intrigued... I never heard of any great composer from NZ yet... there is probably I guess... do you know any web site where I could hear some of their music ?... I don't mean people that redo baroque or classical music... I mean international stature composers.

Yeah, we don't really have alot. Or any.