|
I love what you've done with this piece. I don't believe Shostakovitch is what this piece suggests to me, it seems much more expressionistic than late romantic, a bit like pierot lunair.
the first 18 bars or so, to me didn't make for a good opening, however, I absolutely loved the bit from 19-27 that was solid gold. a bit of an atonal "club footed tango" it was disonant, but the rhythmic drive and atonal melodic fragments set it off very well, I was quite sad it ended so quick, perhaps you could expand it more and/or bring it back later in the piece. The portion from 28-39 (even though it was just a recapitulation of the opening idea) was more than tolerable as a divergent idea. 40-75 again amazing rhythmic drive complimented the tonal liberties taken with the melodic fragments and the closing statement at 76 and 77 was the perfect way to cap of that section. I have no comment on the incomplete portion at the end other than a suggestion that you go into 2/4 using the final two beats of the final measure as a new motif, just a suggestion.
All in all a tremendous start to what I hope will be a tremendous piece when complete
|