Quote:
Originally Posted by 920bpm
Would the fact that I have only half the first viiolins playing the melody with all the violas keep the melody's sound fairly viola-ish/"dark"?
|
No, it wouldn't. Having any violins at all playing the melody would make the sound brighter.
Also, keep in mind that halving the number of players on a part doesn't actually cut the volume in half - it turns out that volume increases proportionally to the square root of the number of players, so half of the first violin section actually generates 70% of the volume of the full section.
Anyway, now looking at the score, I see that you have your violins playing an octave above the violas. What you're actually going to get in this case is almost a pure violin sound, with the violas reinforcing it. You can get a darker sound by having the violins playing in unison with the violas, as they would be playing on their lower strings as well as no longer sticking out above everyone else. This is very possible in what you've written: I see no notes in the viola part that are not playable on a violin.
Part of the problem here, also, is that the inside 1st violins and the 2nd violins cross the viola melody fairly frequently, and are generally in the same register. In order to emphasize a melody in the middle or lower registers, the general idea should be to clear a "highway" for the melody by leaving a bit of space above and below the melody.
What I would do here, then, is either have a half-section of violins double the violas
in unison rather than at the octave, or let the violas play the melody alone. I would also move some of the other material in the violin parts up an octave, allowing the violas to stand out in their register.
__________________
Andrew Hsieh
Medical Student and Composer
View my profile
The piano quartet is COMPLETE!!!
Please note that I will not review the following without a very good reason:
1) MP3-only posts: no score + outside link = bad deal. Especially true because I'm on dialup when at home.
2) Shoutbox or PM spam: excessive shameless plugs get very annoying very fast.
3) Pieces written in a short time or with little effort: if it's not worth the composer's time and energy, then it's not worth mine either.