|
Modulating to different tonal centers seems like something predominantly Western. I've read of thoughtful classical Indian composers being appalled by changing tonal centers at concerts, and getting up and leaving. I don't understand exactly what such people have against changing tonal centers, but then again I don't understand why we do it in the first place.
Changing modes, while keeping the same tonal center, I can understand more. It offers a change in the harmony of the music; a new flavor. But when it comes to changing from C ionian to G ionian, for example, what is the use or novelty besides the modulation itself? I know the assumption that it is supposed to create excitement or tension, even if the listener is not aware of it, but what is there to objectively support that notion? The only real use I can see, is to shift the range so that different timbres can be used for certain intervals, but how often do composers actually modulate for that reason?
Any insight? I would be appreciative to learn of something I'm missing here.
|