Jump to content

How high can a Bb clarinet play p or pp?


920bpm

Recommended Posts

except for the highest notes, all can be playable with ppp, pppp, and all the ps you want ..... a whisper ....

EDIT:

Ups! sorry I didn't see the "how high" in the title .....

Well I think F6 is too high, .... from C5 starts getting difficult for a true ppp ..... maybe a very good player can do it up that F5 and higher

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

I always take expression notation to be a sort of relative thing so wouldn't writing ppp on a very high note, even if it's impossible to play that soft and still be audible, be perfectly valid? I would imagine the performer taking it as, "Play this high note as soft as humanly possible," without concern for whether an exact amount of force is being used. It's like arguing over whether someone is playing ppp or pppp, how can you really tell?

Of course, my assumptions are totally off if it's just not possible to play a high note without playing particularly loud on the clarinet.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I always take expression notation to be a sort of relative thing so wouldn't writing ppp on a very high note, even if it's impossible to play that soft and still be audible, be perfectly valid? I would imagine the performer taking it as, "Play this high note as soft as humanly possible," without concern for whether an exact amount of force is being used.

I tend to agree. There are many scores that write a pianissimo for, say, an oboe note in the lowest register, even while the composer is perfectly aware that it will still sound like a foghorn. It just means "try your best to play softly". But this all sort of depends on how knowledgeable about an instrument you come off as a composer. If you write this without being aware of the relative possible dynamic of this instrument in this register, then you have simply failed to do your homework and the performer might very well realize that and see your high-note clarinet ppp simply as an expression of your ignorance - and therefore choose to ignore it. If you write your score very carefully however and consider the possibilities of the instrument in detail, the perfomer is much more likely to realize that you meant this ppp as a mere ideal to strive for.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would think written C above the staff. It is the highest note before you are controlling squeaks with stranger fingerings, and it is only a little bit of the clarinet in use. really fabulous players could play higher. Myself, I can breathe out the highest note on the clarinet (super C) at a piano dynamic, but I can't play the note a step beneath it to save my life.

SOOO i would say C (Bb concert)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I always take expression notation to be a sort of relative thing so wouldn't writing ppp on a very high note, even if it's impossible to play that soft and still be audible, be perfectly valid? I would imagine the performer taking it as, "Play this high note as soft as humanly possible," without concern for whether an exact amount of force is being used. It's like arguing over whether someone is playing ppp or pppp, how can you really tell?

Of course, my assumptions are totally off if it's just not possible to play a high note without playing particularly loud on the clarinet.

My composition teacher, who studied with Morton Feldman, related an interesting anecdote to me about this very subject. Apparently, upon being questioned by one of his students about why he had written a very very high note on the clarinet to be played extremely quietly, Feldman responded, "Of course they'll never be able to play it, but it'll sound fantastic when they try!"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My composition teacher, who studied with Morton Feldman, related an interesting anecdote to me about this very subject. Apparently, upon being questioned by one of his students about why he had written a very very high note on the clarinet to be play extremely quietly, Feldman responded, "Of course they'll never be able to play it, but it'll sound fantastic when they try!"

Hah, I like that. That's taking the coercion aspect of notation to the extreme.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As high as the clarinet can go(appr. D7, conc. C7), but for many clarinettists it might be preferable to be able to start a bit louder, like p, and then diminuendo to ppp. I find it easier the higher it gets, so everywhere above G6 I can play as soft as I want. It is actually slightly harder below G6, down the fifth to the C above the treble staff.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ab Clarinet ?

that's an other clarinet or a larger barrel ?

Bb and A clarinets are the same you only change the barrel (in A the barrel is a bit larger so the whole clarinet sound half a tone lower)

if it's the barrel it could be build by a instrument builder, I know one but he would have to get a very large barrel and then reduce it a little, besides I don't know if the clarinet will become detuned by the changed total lengh.

if it is a different clarinet, I have never seen one, (if they exist) even rarer than Metal Clarinets

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ab Clarinet ?

that's an other clarinet or a larger barrel ?

Bb and A clarinets are the same you only change the barrel (in A the barrel is a bit larger so the whole clarinet sound half a tone lower)

if it's the barrel it could be build by a instrument builder, I know one but he would have to get a very large barrel and then reduce it a little, besides I don't know if the clarinet will become detuned by the changed total lengh.

if it is a different clarinet, I have never seen one, (if they exist) even rarer than Metal Clarinets

Ab clarinet is a rare clarinet that is even higher than an Eb. It's not a low clarinet at all. Sometimes the Turks will use it, but that's all I know with it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

oooooh I see, I didn't know that thingy ... this one isn't it ?

lab.gif

1176AbS_ko.jpg

:laugh: really funny ....

yeah, it must be hard to find one of those....

It is called Sopranino Clarinet ...

isn't Eb/D Clarinet already a Sopranino ? ..... "Soprillo" could be the term

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 weeks later...
What about the lower end of the range? Right now I'm writing a piece where I want a pp for Bb clarinet at F#3 and briefly at E3. Is that feasible? Should I consider switching it to an alto clarinet?

Alto clarinet is cool, but it is possible on a Bb clarinet. Don't bother thinking about that. Oboes are the ones where you REALLY gotta be careful on the low range. Soft is medium, medium is loud, and loud is honky. lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...