Jump to content

New York Philharmonic Performance Interrupted By Cell Phone


Tokkemon

  

13 members have voted

  1. 1. Did Alan Gilbert do the right thing by stopping the music for a cell phone?

    • Yes, absolutely.
      10
    • No. Trudge onward!
      2
    • Maybe.
      0
    • I don't know/No Opinion
      1


Recommended Posts

On Tuesday a very rare thing happened: conductor Alan Gilbert of the New York Philharmonic put down his baton and stopped the music after a patron's cell phone kept ringing in a performance of Mahler 9.

http://www.foxnews.com/us/2012/01/12/ringing-cellphone-disrupts-new-york-philharmonic-performance/

The story is also available in many different news outlets.

What do you think of the situation? Did Gilbert to the right thing? Should there be more measures to limit technological devices in the hall? Share your thoughts.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What Allan Gilbert did was absolutely right. He was just demanding respect for himself, the NYPO... and Mahler!!!!!!!!

I only wish it had been the Sixth Symphony instead of the Ninth. Thus he could have used one of the hammerschlags on the cell phone and the other one(s) on its owner.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As usual, there's more than one side to a story. If his story can be trusted, he had put the phone in silent mode. The technology's design and user experience are at least partly to blame here (as well as the man's unfamiliarity with a new device). I mean, who would expect a device in "silent" mode to be capable of making sound?

Of course, after you learn about those kind of quirks, you realize that just being muted isn't enough. Of course, I turn mine fully off when I'm at the symphony.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As usual, there's more than one side to a story. If his story can be trusted, he had put the phone in silent mode. The technology's design and user experience are at least partly to blame here (as well as the man's unfamiliarity with a new device). I mean, who would expect a device in "silent" mode to be capable of making sound?

Of course, after you learn about those kind of quirks, you realize that just being muted isn't enough. Of course, I turn mine fully off when I'm at the symphony.

For precisely this reason, at times like this, and even when I'm in a rehearsal, I leave my phone locked in the glove compartment of my car. Something like this happened to me once: I had set my phone to silent during a service at church, and inexplicably the alarm went off. Turns out that the device was designed to override the silent setting when the alarm clock kicks in - most inconvenient in my case, but I can see why it does it. Since you never know when something like that is going to happen, whether the device itself does it for some reason, or you accidentally hit a button while it's in your pocket, or whatever, maybe it's best to just leave the phone somewhere else if you can.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yup, same. I have voicemail precisely for when the 'phone's off. Unless the message is that my house is on fire or I am about to be assassinated, I can reasonably assume that responding to your call can wait until I have finished rehearsal/concert/driving/meeting/swimming/other concern. This story is almost certainly going to be filed under 'examples of classical music being pretentious and elitist' by those who love to hate it, despite the conductor being completely right to protest. Silence from an audience is considered to be as much a part of a modern concert as the opposite is at a sports match.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The right to use a cell phone has to be earned, imo. Earned by, for example, not using it while you're out eating with someone, not using it whilst in a conversation and making sure it is completely off when it should be, like in a concert, be it a concert by aunt Mary and uncle James on the piano in the local bar, or the New York Philharmonic...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is interesting and all, but it's not that it's the only such precedent in history. Can't help but mention Franz Liszt who stopped playing when Nicholas I of Russia started talking with his adjutants. (Needless to say, he became a persona non grata in Saint-Petersburg since then! :nod:)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I guess it raises interesting questions...what about fireworks during the 1812 Overture? Surely just another external noise not originally scored by the composer...I'm only playing Devil's advocate :)

He did score cannon shots. And I think he did allow for the use of fireworks, despite not "scoring" them.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...