March Competition Submissions Thread (V.2)

[Guest Anders]

NOTE: The fifth competitor, Invisionary, has withdrawn from this contest

This is the submissions thread for the March composition competition - in which the participants were to create a sonata (in whatever form they desired) for solo keyboard. In this thread you will listen to all of the pieces, and vote for the one which you like the most.

Note that if this poll ends in a draw, the piece that gets the most support through actual posted commentary will win. So, you are encouraged to offer a short, or indepth if you so wish, comment on each work. Specify which piece you'd rathe 1st, which piece you'd rate second.. and so on..

The submitted pieces are:

1. Sonata In G Minor - By Ralph Bernardy

- MIDI - SCORE -

2. Sonata For Celesta - By Mark Gower

- MIDI - SCORE -

3. Piano Sonata ''Logical Fallacy'' - By Kia P.

- SCORE - MIDI -

4. Sonata In G# Minor - By ''lind''

- SCORE - MIDI -

[Mark]

nice thread Anders, I'll give them all a listen and vote tomorrow, but from the few I've heard in the other thread, the standard seems high :whistling:

[Jeremiah Hong]

You forgot Jeremy's. :unsure:

[Guest Anders]

Jeremy has withdrawn from this competition, unfortunately.

[Jeremiah Hong]

Why, he realized his piece sucked? jk :unsure:...He was probably frustrated with all the disorder.

[violinfiddler]

Jeremy has withdrawn from this competition, unfortunately.

That stinks, his was the best.

[Guest Anders]

Hmm.. well. I thought his submission was impeccably crafted, but quite boring.

I'm going to go for either the logical fallacy, or the celesta sonata.. Let's see..

[Guest CreationArtist]

Please change my vote to Ralph's piece ( <- an very interesting piece by a composer that seems to have lots of potential to break forth this new style of music I forsee for the 21st Century). Anyway, I made an error. Please do this ASAP. Thanks.

[Guest Anders]

Mike, could you help me here? :whistling:

PS: Ca, just be aware that it will say you've voted for nothing. But the vote will be changed.

[Guest Anders]

This poll will be run for 1 week.

[Guest CreationArtist]

Here's the link to a recording of Ralph's piece on my Bosy just for your info. Only in Mp3, though, sorry. Tell me if you like the revised ending.

EarTraumaforMe - eSnips, share anything

[Guest Anders]

bUMP

[Guest Anders]

Results:

1st - Sonata In G Minor with 10 votes

2nd - Piano Sonata ''Logical Fallacy'' with 2 votes

3rd - Sonata For Celesta and Sonata in G sharp minor with 1 vote each

Congratulations to Ralph! :)

[bob_the_sane]

Well done Ralph.

One thing, the sonata in G sharp minor actually got two votes, because CreationArtist's (Matt's? Is that right?) vote doesn't show up except when you click on the number of votes.

[Guest Anders]

Matt requested to have his vote changed to Sonata in G minor. :)

[bob_the_sane]

I know, but you didn't count his vote when you posted the results.

It's nothing really, Ralph wins anyway...

[ralphb]

Thank you, guys :) I'm delighted. And thanks to CreationArtist for his recording of my piece, which is much better than the midi file.

Hopefully more people will review my other works now ;-)

[Guest Anders]

:)

I know, but you didn't count his vote when you posted the results.

It's nothing really, Ralph wins anyway...

Yes I did. It just doesen't show up when you click view poll. you'll see there's 10 votes, but only 9 people are listed as having voted. vBulletin is a bit annoying when it comes to changing votes.

[bob_the_sane]

Ah, ok, I got confused:wacko:

Congrats Ralph:)

[KSP]

Congratratulations, Ralph! I personally liked the contrasting themes, and development of your piece the best. :)

Posting MP3s of submissions is a good idea. I'll post a recording of mine also soon.

[Guest CreationArtist]

So what's the deal with this month?

[William K.]

I think it would be pretty cool to have this month be a chamber music type thing... just a suggestion :)

[Mike]

We won't be running a monthly competition for April because the Symphonic Competition deadline has just passed. Once that's over and done with, we'll try to arrange something for May.

[Guest CreationArtist]

Maybe we can have a slightly more ambitious competition for May and start a couple of weeks early. --say a piano concerto movement.

[violinfiddler]

Let's do a chamber music competiton. How about a string trio competition?