Gossamer

Because he is trying to prove his thoughts and intellect are superior to others because for some inexplicable reason he believes that the only worthwhile music is baroque. He cannot do this so he is resorting to a sort of pseudo science to 'prove' his argument. If you know anything about science and feel you must base your music on some universal scientific truths then the only real music is chance music I guess. I can only assume that the science he knows is not what the rest of the world knows as science, probably some young earther or some madness like that.

It has to be said that you are knocking your head against a brick wall here, this guy knows nothing about anything, just keeps harping on about laws of nature with no reference to anything scientific whilst obfuscating his language in scientific sounding terms. You can't win. He has no concept of the idea of subjectivity and is so closed minded that he likes nothing after/outside of the baroque period. I say leave him be, if his music is as natural and organic as he believes then surely his resounding success and fame will prove that his music conforms to the eternal laws of nature more accurately than anyone who uses anything other than first year elementary harmony... First post on the site, I have been a lurker for a little while but this topic is mind bendingly frustrating so felt I should chime in.