Jump to content
  • Chatbox

    Please consider reviewing as well as posting. Not only does it help balance the number of works on the site, but it helps you get involved! You may think you have nothing to add, but something as simple as "this was cool because of this part" or "something about 0:35 threw me off a bit" does help. Thanks!
    You don't have permission to chat.
    Load More


  1. Board

    1. Announcements and Technical Problems

      Check here for the latest news, report technical problems with the board, or submit your suggestions

    2. Young Composers Magazine

      All topics related to the Young Composers Magazine go here.  If you are interested in signing up, please join our magazine club.

  2. Upload Your Compositions for Analysis or Feedback

    1. Orchestral and Large Ensemble

      Upload compositions which use an orchestra or a large ensemble (defined as one requiring a conductor)

    2. Chamber Music

      Upload compositions written for a small group of instruments (including works with piano), or for solo instruments (other than works for solo keyboard)

    3. Choral, Vocal

      Upload compositions that extensively make use of one or more singers, whether in the form of a soloist or a chorus

    4. Piano Music, Solo Keyboard

      Upload piano and solo keyboard works

    5. Incidental Music and Soundtracks

      Upload video game music, film music and other forms not primarily intended for the concert stage

    6. Jazz, Band, Pop, Rock

      Upload Jazz, Band or Pop/Rock compositions

    7. Electronic

      Upload music which makes use of electronic resources

    8. Incomplete Works; Writer's Block and Suggestions

      Works here must be attached using the forum's attachment method. Incomplete works will not be categorized in the network.

  3. Community

    1. Masterclasses

      Contains a selection of Masterclasses.

    2. Music Appreciation: Suggest Works or Articles

      Suggest works and discuss past and/or present events, for the sake of Music Appreciation.  Link to YouTube videos, iTunes links, online articles and composers websites.

    3. Composers' Headquarters

      General discussion on composer-related issues and music composition.

    4. Repertoire

      Talk about musical repertoire, from full-blown orchestral works to solo piano pieces

    5. Performance

      Discuss the performance of music here, such as the characteristics and limitations of different instruments

    6. Advice and Techniques

      Offer informal advice on methods of composition, compositional technique (e.g., fugue writing, chorale-style harmonization), etc., that you feel may be of benefit and interest to our members.

  4. Competitions and Collaboration

    1. Competition Hall of Fame

      A list of winning works of all of our competitions

    2. Monthly Competitions

      NEW Smaller-scale competitions held on a monthly basis

    3. Collaborative Works

      Work on a piece with other composers

    4. Challenges

      "Little creative exercises for composers to think outside of the box."

    5. External Competitions

      External competitions that are not hosted by Young Composers.

  5. Technological

    1. Finale and Sibelius Help Desk

      Post questions about Finale or Sibelius here

    2. Sound Libraries

      Discuss different sound libraries. This is also the place to talk about software samplers, such as EWQL, VSL, GPO, Kontakt and Gigastudio

  • Upcoming Events

    No upcoming events found
  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 10 Guests (See full list)

    There are no registered users currently online

  • Music Jotter Windows Demo

  • Works With Few Reviews

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • What/who does this intro sound like?  If I can figure out what, I can change it enough to keep the flavor of the original, but still stand alone on its own two musical feet.  Name that tune!  Any guesses? Furtak-Psalm 24.mid
    • It's generally a very good piece. I don't think you use the upper percussion too much. If there's one thing I was to gripe on majorly it would be the overall pitch (as opposed to pitch class) range of the band; it's very constant, even if in different dynamics, and it makes the piece sound a little static. I get that support in the bass or upper voice is pretty standard orchestration practice, but I hate it when it's taught that way. But for a normal band who doesn't care about this stuff, it's a really good work.
    • This kind-of-but-not-really tonal center on Bb in addition to the 9th leaps in the top voice make some of this sound superfluous. I don't really get a clear reason for a lot of choices, and the cascading effect of a lot of minimalism is instead heard as stratified entrances. Reasons for this include crossed voices and not filling in a modal triad whenever one appears. This makes everything sound almost like a MIDI recreation of a piece that went wrong.
      There was a moment where a modulation to Bb minor happened, which was cool, but the effect is lost because the processes you have going around it aren't heard as a constancy undergoing change; it just sounds like a constancy, and it makes a lot of this sound very static; almost unmoving despite the motion. 
    • This whole V/vi -> I thing you do is interesting, but maybe a bit overdone, especially since the voice leading is the same every time. This is especially awkward at 2:04 (m. 32) when the moment is undercut by the familiarity with the material.
      Your counterpoint begins to get a bit rough around the minute mark. Passing tones against a static voice in oblique motion will not be heard as such; it's either a suspension or a retardation and both need to be substantiated.
      Flutes at 24 could occasionally be in octaves to vary it up, give a bit of range. 
      Interesting bit of hemiola at the end there. I'm not sure what the effect of that is.
    • There seems to be a little bit of Klangfarbenmelodie with your timbres, but not all of them blend super well. The passage at around :28 lacks cohesion because of a lack of octave equivalence.
      Mode mixture between major and Mixolydian modes was nice, but underutilized. 
      Cymbals can be quieter.
      The pseudo modulation to the relative minor was cool in the way it was underplayed/unannounced. I don't think it works super well to not announce the return, however.