themanonthehill

I have always composed on my keyboard, mainly because I don't have a piano! However, I am just about to buy my first piano and expect to compose on that. But I have just seen a video of some guy composing on his keyboard, with a piano sitting unused in the background - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TfqmbNvm0Q8. Why would you do this? Is it better to compose initially on a keyboard before playing it properly on a piano?

Wow, thanks everyone for the considered responses. This is very useful indeed and has given me a great place to start. I have answered the questions below in-case this gives any more insights for me. :-) How much are you willing to spend? About $5-10K, but flexible for the right piano. Do you want an upright or a grand? An upright will fit better in my house. How big is the room you're putting it in? A little tight unfortunately... What level of performance are you at? (going to uni or just do piano for fun). It's been a hobby for a long time, but I am looking to step it up. Do you like a specific brand or feature? (e.g Yamaha, "ivory" keys etc.). I have used Yamaha up to now. I like this a lot, but am open to alternatives. Thanks again!

Hi, I am finally buying a piano and moving on from my electric keyboard. I have dreamt of this for so long, but have now become confused over what to buy! There are so many choices and as this is a purchase for life, I want to get it right. Do you have any tips when deciding what piano to buy or any specific recommendations? Many thanks, Simon

Very pretty and delicate. I love music that conveys both sadness and hope, it gives a real emotive feel.

Very nice indeed. Gentle, positive and uplifting.