November 5Nov 5 This is a completely reworked version of my earlier piece, Floating Dance. It originally started out as a waltz, but as I kept working on it, the music gradually took a different direction. It eventually became something quite different, free from any traditional musical form.I hope you enjoy this new version! „Melodic Rhapsody8“.pdf„Melodic Rhapsody8“.mp3 Edited November 6Nov 6 by Tristan25
November 10Nov 10 Hi there, in the opening I got this Scott Joplin feel and I became quite invested; however, that initial feel was lost as the material quickly progressed. I didn't feel/experience a particular direction in the piece either harmonically or thematically. It just seemed to wander. I would reexamine the opening theme and attempt to develop it further.Mark
Monday at 04:06 PM1 day Hello Tristan, thank you for sharing the reworked version — I listened and followed the score, and I enjoyed hearing how the piece has moved away from its waltz origins into something freer. The opening works well: in 3/4 at Moderato, the right hand's singing line sits clearly over the left hand's chordal accompaniment, and the little triplet turn in bar 4 gives the melody a gentle lift before the rising arpeggiated figures in bars 6–8 open it out into a longer, flowing phrase. That contrast between the song-like opening and the more rhapsodic, free-flowing middle is what gives the piece its character. One suggestion, echoing Mark's comment: the opening theme is so memorable that I wanted to hear it return or develop more later on, so you could try bringing a varied form of it back near the end, perhaps in a different register or with a fuller left-hand texture, to tie the rhapsody together. Did the reworking change the ending as well, or did the free-form middle grow out of the original waltz ending?
4 hours ago4 hr Author ! On 11/10/2026 at 4:12 PM, MJFOBOE said:Hi there, in the opening I got this Scott Joplin feel and I became quite invested; however, that initial feel was lost as the material quickly progressed. I didn't feel/experience a particular direction in the piece either harmonically or thematically. It just seemed to wander.I would reexamine the opening theme and attempt to develop it further.MarkOn 11/16/2026 at 5:06 PM, Ali Baghbani said:Hello Tristan, thank you for sharing the reworked version — I listened and followed the score, and I enjoyed hearing how the piece has moved away from its waltz origins into something freer. The opening works well: in 3/4 at Moderato, the right hand's singing line sits clearly over the left hand's chordal accompaniment, and the little triplet turn in bar 4 gives the melody a gentle lift before the rising arpeggiated figures in bars 6–8 open it out into a longer, flowing phrase. That contrast between the song-like opening and the more rhapsodic, free-flowing middle is what gives the piece its character. One suggestion, echoing Mark's comment: the opening theme is so memorable that I wanted to hear it return or develop more later on, so you could try bringing a varied form of it back near the end, perhaps in a different register or with a fuller left-hand texture, to tie the rhapsody together. Did the reworking change the ending as well, or did the free-form middle grow out of the original waltz ending?Thank you both so much for the detailed feedback!Your comments really inspired me: I cut out the harsher parts and wrote about 50 new measures that develop the opening motif in a much more waltz-like, flowing, and melodic way. „Melodic Rhapsody 2“.mp3 „Melodic Rhapsody 2“.pdf Edited 4 hours ago4 hr by Tristan25
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.