November 5Nov 5 This is a completely reworked version of my earlier piece, Floating Dance. It originally started out as a waltz, but as I kept working on it, the music gradually took a different direction. It eventually became something quite different, free from any traditional musical form.I hope you enjoy this new version! „Melodic Rhapsody8“.pdf„Melodic Rhapsody8“.mp3 Edited November 6Nov 6 by Tristan25
November 10Nov 10 Hi there, in the opening I got this Scott Joplin feel and I became quite invested; however, that initial feel was lost as the material quickly progressed. I didn't feel/experience a particular direction in the piece either harmonically or thematically. It just seemed to wander. I would reexamine the opening theme and attempt to develop it further.Mark
Monday at 04:06 PM3 days Hello Tristan, thank you for sharing the reworked version — I listened and followed the score, and I enjoyed hearing how the piece has moved away from its waltz origins into something freer. The opening works well: in 3/4 at Moderato, the right hand's singing line sits clearly over the left hand's chordal accompaniment, and the little triplet turn in bar 4 gives the melody a gentle lift before the rising arpeggiated figures in bars 6–8 open it out into a longer, flowing phrase. That contrast between the song-like opening and the more rhapsodic, free-flowing middle is what gives the piece its character. One suggestion, echoing Mark's comment: the opening theme is so memorable that I wanted to hear it return or develop more later on, so you could try bringing a varied form of it back near the end, perhaps in a different register or with a fuller left-hand texture, to tie the rhapsody together. Did the reworking change the ending as well, or did the free-form middle grow out of the original waltz ending?
Yesterday at 07:35 AM1 day Author ! On 11/10/2026 at 4:12 PM, MJFOBOE said:Hi there, in the opening I got this Scott Joplin feel and I became quite invested; however, that initial feel was lost as the material quickly progressed. I didn't feel/experience a particular direction in the piece either harmonically or thematically. It just seemed to wander.I would reexamine the opening theme and attempt to develop it further.MarkOn 11/16/2026 at 5:06 PM, Ali Baghbani said:Hello Tristan, thank you for sharing the reworked version — I listened and followed the score, and I enjoyed hearing how the piece has moved away from its waltz origins into something freer. The opening works well: in 3/4 at Moderato, the right hand's singing line sits clearly over the left hand's chordal accompaniment, and the little triplet turn in bar 4 gives the melody a gentle lift before the rising arpeggiated figures in bars 6–8 open it out into a longer, flowing phrase. That contrast between the song-like opening and the more rhapsodic, free-flowing middle is what gives the piece its character. One suggestion, echoing Mark's comment: the opening theme is so memorable that I wanted to hear it return or develop more later on, so you could try bringing a varied form of it back near the end, perhaps in a different register or with a fuller left-hand texture, to tie the rhapsody together. Did the reworking change the ending as well, or did the free-form middle grow out of the original waltz ending?Thank you both so much for the detailed feedback!Your comments really inspired me: I cut out the harsher parts and wrote about 50 new measures that develop the opening motif in a much more waltz-like, flowing, and melodic way. „Melodic Rhapsody 2“.mp3 „Melodic Rhapsody 2“.pdf Edited yesterday at 07:37 AM1 day by Tristan25
53 minutes ago53 min Thank you for sharing the new version, Tristan — I listened to Melodic Rhapsody 2, and the change is clear. The opening motif now flows on in that waltz-like way you describe, and cutting the harsher passages lets the melody carry through more continuously, especially as the song-like opening opens out into the longer, flowing phrases. One thought: the opening theme is still so memorable that a varied return of it near the end, perhaps in a different register, could tie the new 50 measures together even more. Did the new ending change as well, or did the free-form middle grow out of the original ending?
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.