Piano Fantasia Competition

Entries

Beautiful Noise (Micah)

Fantasia in A minor.pdf - File Shared from Box.net - Free Online File Storage

Fantasia in A minor.WAV - File Shared from Box.net - Free Online File Storage

gamma (eric darr)

the pdf: Fantasia Op.1 - Lullaby.pdf - File Shared from Box.net - Free Online File Storage

the mp3: Lullaby.mp3 - File Shared from Box.net - Free Online File Storage

pianoplayer18 (j.p. dennis)

The War of Fantasia - Movement I

Start Player

The War of Fantasia - Movement II

Start Player

viktor sethy

imp1 aug.25.mp3 - File Shared from Box.net - Free Online File Storage

imp2 aug.25.mp3 - File Shared from Box.net - Free Online File Storage

imp3 aug.25.mp3 - File Shared from Box.net - Free Online File Storage

if your entry is missing because of email/posting/i just missed it :blush: issues, tell me as quickly as possible.

JP Dennis, I need an mp3 download and PDF for your piece. I can't get the soundclick links to work.

JP Dennis, I need an mp3 download and PDF for your piece. I can't get the soundclick links to work.

Sent you a message to ask you which e-mail to send it to. Thanks.

SO, is this still judging or did it commit suicide?

SO, is this still judging or did it commit suicide?

It's still judging, sorry, I should have posted, considering that it is taking so long...

Tokkemon didn't get the original message I had sent with all the entries - Jimmyjuicin's computer has failed, they are both working on the scores now.

Judges, please finish your scoring by November 30th at Midnight!

The WannaBeChopin's Scoring.

Hehe, Hi. Lucky I went on to Young Composers today, :P Sorry for being so late. I am recovering from Swine Flu at the moment. :P

Micah- 76/100 I liked this a lot, however sometimes I felt it suddenly stopped, but maybe this was the desire effect. Now I can go all cadencial on you!! The piece didn't end with a cadence :sadtears:! Anyway, I thought this was a nice composition with nice ideas. I really liked how it flowed, but sometimes it just stopped, which I didn't really like. It didn't really capture the FANTASIA part of it, it was just a tad predictable.

Eric Darr- 69/100- Very "Nice" I did enjoy it. (But it didn't end with a cadence!) Although It was a bit higgle-ti-pigglety, (With the triplets.) I still didn't think it had the dramatic qualities of a Fantasia though.

PianoMan- 73/100 A Realy Fantasia I would say, although the start 3 chords with their varations did get slightly repetetive after a while. It was interesting putting them in two movements, a strange idea. Their wasn't really a tune in the first movement their was only this motiff of three chords which got rather repetetive. their was a glimmer of hope the second movement would turn out to be a nice slow bit to make into a true unpredictable fantasia but this didn't really happen. :P

Sethy- 65/100 Jazzy. :) Although not my taste it could be other people's taste. Again this piece did not really have a tune although the harmony was nice. And How long does this piece go on for? :o I Went away not realizing I left the piece on for twenty minute and it was still playing!

cool cool, so is that it, or are you going to take tokkemons or jimmyjuicin's judging yet?

I don't really care what I get, I just want the feedback from the judges...