JorgeDavid Posted 5 hours ago Posted 5 hours ago (edited) Hello everyone, I’m working on a new piece that’s more harmonically adventurous than my usual style and would love your feedback. It was originally for flute and piano, but since I did not like the flute sound from Musescore, I used a soprano voice instead. That made me consider turning it into a Lied with syllables rather than lyrics (since I can’t write lyrics). The main theme began as a neotonal composition practice exercise based on a post in the Talkclassical forum: Step 1. Write a diatonic melody in a mode missing one note. Step 2. Use a different mode or scale for the harmony. My melody is in C Ionian without F, and the harmony is C ascending melodic minor (C major with Eb, though I ended up using E here and there too). I later added a B section with the melody focusing on the unused note F. The form is [:A:][:BA:]. I’m unsure about a few things: Does the piece and structure work overall? Does the harmony work? (I am still considering piano voicings in section B, particularly in m.10, but A is finished). Since A repeats four times (and it is a period, so there is internal repetition too). Should I get rid of the initial repetition of A? Or maybe varying the harmony/accompaniment in the second repetition or even adding a C section? I always get stuck with same simple form and I also do not know how to reharmonize themes without making it lose the balance. Does it work better as a vocal piece or another instrument would be better (specially since there are no lyrics)? Not sure if it should be a Lied, a Song without words, a Romance, or what. Is there a way to indicate that the melody can be played with any suitable instrument freely? Technically it is in C Minor (it starts and ends in it) but since it uses mostly natural A and natural B throughout, and natural E on the melody, I used the Cmaj key signature. Is that okay or I should change it to using three flats like in natural C minor? Thanks for listening and any feedback is welcome! PD: I found out that the first 4 notes and main motive of the piece (and the mood, because of the vocal singer) is similar to Jerry Goldsmith's theme to 'The Illustrated Man'. I never heard it before so it was a pure coincidence. I think the harmonization of those 4 notes is different, though. Edited 3 hours ago by JorgeDavid MP3 Play / pause JavaScript is required. 0:00 0:00 volume > next menu Neotonal_Lied_or_Romance > next PDF Neotonal_Lied_or_Romance Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.