All Activity
Past hour
-
My first piece for an ensemble, Sinfonietta for Wind Instruments
Hello I’ve listened to Part 1 on YouTube, because I like to look at the score. Your ideas are very good, but I think there are a few things to consider in terms of orchestration. I’m no expert, but that’s my opinion. The opening catches the ear because I don’t think those pp dynamics up there on the flute are feasible. The clarinets are playing figures that are typical of the piano – not very idiomatic – but, what’s more, with no rest for so many bars, they need to catch their breath. Another thing I’ve noticed is those very long notes that form the harmony; they don’t sound right on these instruments. The harmonic foundation needs to move; in fact, in an orchestra, everything has to be alive.
-
Bach - Capriccio BWV 992 (partial orchestration)
Hello I love the way it sounds. I can’t remember the original – I’d have to listen to it again to compare – but I don’t need to, as it works really well for me just as it is. I don’t know which parts have been added, but as it all sounds very cohesive, I don’t mind. I think that when you orchestrate something, you can be very, very literal or the complete opposite; the important thing is to do it with flair or with a purpose. The chromatic descents sound phenomenal. The oboe with the muted trumpet is a combination that might seem a bit odd at first, but when the trumpet is muted, they blend together beautifully. When the full string section comes in on bar 34 – although it’s not exactly the same, even in terms of instrumental density – it reminded me of Wagner, or Maher. Perhaps because of the chromaticism present. What a crazy but intriguing idea – Bach-Wagner. I’m sure Wagner studied Bach.
-
A Waltz for Ning
Hello A very moving piece. I think it ties in very well with the Romantic tradition – what remains of it, at least. I love watching people play. But as my interest lies in composition, I like to look at the scores – if there are any – as I always learn something from them. I liked the linear descent at 1:24.
Today
-
A Waltz for Ning
Hello Ali, thank you for your comment. I think you've understood my piece. I am also not 100% sure about the current ending either. You've given me some ideas to consider for the ending, thanks. I can post a score, though I am not very good at engraving. I think the current score I have for this one is a bit messy!
-
Looking for peer reviews for this piano and bass clarinet piece: Sad Song, April 2026
That sounds like a good direction, Laurent — it fits what I heard in the piece, too. The piano's repeated pattern is lovely in the first nine bars, but when it stays full while the bass clarinet holds its long notes, the clarinet has to work hard to be heard. Simplifying or muting the piano just in those moments should let its low, warm line come through without losing the piano's character. Will you try it first in the opening, or in the passages where the clarinet holds its longest notes?
-
Another start to a fugue
Hello, thank you for sharing this fugue start — I listened to the full 32 seconds, and the subject in Db major has a clear, singing shape that I could follow easily as it begins to unfold. I liked how the entries overlap and the texture thickens, which already gives it a fugal feel even in such a short opening. One suggestion: since you mentioned the last bar feels impossible to play, it might be worth thinning the voices there for a moment, or giving the lower voice a rest, so the line can breathe before the next entry. Are you planning to answer the subject in the dominant next, or to develop it freely first?
-
Ali Baghbani started following Ruby's Prayer (Ballad in Eb Major for Piano) and Another start to a fugue
-
Ruby's Prayer (Ballad in Eb Major for Piano)
Hello JorgeDavid, thank you for sharing this — I listened to your performance and followed the score in the video. I enjoyed how the melody in Eb major keeps its singing, ballad character through the AABABA form, and the classical arrangement suits it well: the harmony feels rich without losing the tune, and the softer pp delicato passages give the return of the A section a gentle, prayer-like quality. One suggestion: since you mentioned keeping tone and volume constant was difficult, it might help to let the left hand stay a little lighter in the A sections, so the melody can stay in front even at a soft dynamic. Did you find the B section, with its different harmony, easier or harder to keep even in tone than the A sections?
-
Melodic Rhapsody
Thank you for sharing the new version, Tristan — I listened to Melodic Rhapsody 2, and the change is clear. The opening motif now flows on in that waltz-like way you describe, and cutting the harsher passages lets the melody carry through more continuously, especially as the song-like opening opens out into the longer, flowing phrases. One thought: the opening theme is still so memorable that a varied return of it near the end, perhaps in a different register, could tie the new 50 measures together even more. Did the new ending change as well, or did the free-form middle grow out of the original ending?
-
Looking for peer reviews for this piano and bass clarinet piece: Sad Song, April 2026
Currently I think I need at times to simplify and occasionally to mute the piano accompaniment to give the clarinet more room.
-
Nocturne in e minor (miniature)
Thank you, islav — that makes complete sense, and I appreciate you explaining it. Leaving the title abstract fits the piece well, since the harmony does so much of the work and the melody stays close to it, and the high descending figure with the fermata in bars 2-3 already gives the listener plenty to imagine without a picture in the title. I also like hearing them as standalone character pieces — each one can keep its own mood that way. Do you have another standalone piece in mind already, or are you letting the next idea arrive on its own?
-
Looking for peer reviews for this piano and bass clarinet piece: Sad Song, April 2026
Thank you, Laurent — I am glad this combination is one you would like to try again, even if you want to solve that small riddle in this piece first. For me, what already works so well is the contrast between the piano's repeated pattern in the first nine bars and the bass clarinet's low, warm entry, and the way the final clarinet phrase settles onto a long note in bar 58. Which passage feels closest to the change you have in mind, or is it more a question of the overall balance between the two instruments?
-
Minuet in C
Thank you for clarifying that, Martynas — a separate prelude makes good sense, and it can stand on its own while still sharing something of the minuet's light, staccato character in 3/4. I like the idea of it as an independent piece rather than a movement, since that leaves you free to give it its own shape and ending. Will you keep the prelude in C major, or try a different key so it has its own colour apart from the minuet?
-
Another start to a fugue
I've started writing another fugue. I have not really paid the closest attention to how possible this is to actually play and I do think the last bar is impossible to play. Also sorry if notation is sloppy. D Flat.pdf D Flat.mp3
-
draingxngceo started following Another start to a fugue
-
Nocturne in e minor (miniature)
Hi relating to your subtitle suggestions, a bit too on the nose for me, i like more abstract titles, to leave the exact imagery open to interpretation. but i appreciate the thought. And no i don't really hear any of my music as parts of a potential collection, just a bunch of stand alone character pieces and ideas. Thank you for your feedback and thoughts
-
Ruby's Prayer (Ballad in Eb Major for Piano)
Hello everyone, I wanted to share the last piece I finished and performed at the piano. It is an arrangement of a jazz ballad lead sheet that I composed, but the arrangement sounds more classical than jazzy. I suspect it might work better arranged as this rather than as a lead sheet, because of the avoid notes that I use here and there. As it is common in jazz, I gave the tune a name so I am using the same name for the piece. The piece in this arrangement is in the form [AABABA]. For those interested in seeing the lead sheet, I attach it as well. It is not a hard piece to play but it was hard for me to keep the tone and volume constant, so sorry about the mistakes. As always any feedback is more than welcome! Thank you and hope you enjoy it! Ruby's_Prayer_Ballad_Lead_Sheet.pdf
-
-
10 Variations for Wind Trio in Gb
YouTube video:
-
Jamie's Casting - "Will I find true love?"
YouTube short:
-
My first piece for an ensemble, Sinfonietta for Wind Instruments
Hello, I am a novice composer and this is my first post on this forum, which I discovered by accident today. This forum is just what I'm looking for, a place to share my compositions to others other than YouTube. I haven't got a lot of experience in composing or orchestration, so please take this in mind. Any constructive criticism would be welcome. I also have a YouTube channel where I upload my compositions: https://www.youtube.com/@tylerplayspiano-2026 video-score_sinfoniettamscx.mp3 video-score_sinfonietta-2mscx.mp3 video-score_sinfonietta-3mscx.mp3
-
-
tylerplayspiano joined the community
Yesterday
-
PeterthePapercomPoser started following Bez nazvu
-
Bez nazvu
<font dir="auto" style="vertical-align: inherit;"><font dir="auto" style="vertical-align: inherit;">Pan Minor 01.11.2026.mp3</font></font>
-
-
Lee Sang Gul joined the community
-
Jack Hopper changed their profile photo
-
Chasing Auroras
I agree with you guys—that castle/mine-like place is beautiful, and not only that, the scenic view from a high place is also wonderful. As for the piece, I enjoyed it—it has a gentle, spacious atmosphere and, as Peter said, tranquil. I think the current version is good, but personally, I think you could lengthen the release, maybe. More like a continuing sound to emphasize more spacious vibes. The same thing is true of the kick drum—add a bit more reverb, not release though. But the most important thing is whether you like it, so if you like that, that is the best thing! It's just my impression, so please don't take this too seriously :) I enjoyed it and am looking forward to hearing your works in the future. Thanks to you, the electronic topic is now revived! P.S. I love your videos—the colors gradually get colorized and the final view of a beautiful place :) Best, Lithl.
-
Melodic Rhapsody
! Thank you both so much for the detailed feedback! Your comments really inspired me: I cut out the harsher parts and wrote about 50 new measures that develop the opening motif in a much more waltz-like, flowing, and melodic way. „Melodic Rhapsody 2“.mp3 „Melodic Rhapsody 2“.pdf
- Chasing Auroras
-
Forty6 started following Chasing Auroras
- We Shall Fight on the Beaches
-
Henry Ng Tsz Kiu started following Chasing Auroras
- Chasing Auroras
-
PeterthePapercomPoser started following Chasing Auroras
-
Persichetti Exercise 3 - 51 for String Quartet
YouTube short: