All Activity

Hello again @Krisp! I really love the lyrical melody of this one! And the constant unpredictable modulations and free tonality is really great and always keeping the listener on their toes! Thanks for sharing this thoroughly enjoyable song! P.S.: I also liked the very impressionistic introduction!

Hello @J. Lee Graham and welcome back to the forum! Wow! What a wonderfully accomplished work! I am glad that despite feeling "unworthy of the material" that you managed to finish it after more than 20 years!!! I also have had such an experience. I started my Variations on "Deck the Halls" for Piano and Orchestra back in the 2000's as well, over a decade before when I ended up finishing it. And it was only thanks to the fact that I learned to write music on paper that I managed to have the discipline to finish it. I totally understand the sentiment! It is hard to limit yourself when writing for period instruments when you know that superior versions of the instruments would in fact have capabilities that would very much facilitate the music in question for the composer. I think I would also leave the piece as-is knowing that there do in fact exist versions of the instruments with the capability to actually perform the piece live, which is ultimately all that I would care about. I have to say that my favorite movement is the Polonaise! What a delight to hear someone include this stately Polish dance in a concerto! I am Polish myself and have danced the Polonaise as a youth in a Polish Folk Dance Ensemble. The dance has all the pomp and nobility of the spirit of Poland! I think it was also you who remarked that your favorite National Anthem is the Mazurek Dabrowskiego in an old thread I read somewhere. I actually have always dreamed of creating a mash-up of the Mazurek with the American National Anthem to create a kind of "Polish-American Heritage Anthem". We'll see if that ever comes to fruition! Thanks for sharing this wonderfully bright piece! I thoroughly enjoyed it!

Hey @L.S Barros! Nice galliard! It does sound very dance-like and jovial! I have a few Baroque-style dances that I've written myself that are in more of a modern style (for string orchestra), but I've never written a galliard or pavane or any of those old Renaissance dances. But I'd really like to - I'm always fascinated by the idea that one could write a dance suite or longer orchestral work with all different kinds of dances from throughout the ages, as well as more modern dances like the tango or salsa. Thanks for sharing! I really like the addition of instruments half way through! And the instruments sound like legitimate early-music instruments! Great job!

Hey @Tunndy and welcome to the forum! I think that both the melody and harmony in this piece are quite unique and personal to you! The piece starts quite underwhelmingly and gives the listener time to get used to its unique melodic content and the waltz rhythm. Then it gets really pompous and dynamic! And despite it being undoubtedly a piece that you will consider a part of your juvenilia, it still shows great talent and musical sense. I think the only part that I find objectionable is that the piece sounds like it's ending for too long. To me the piece sounds like it could have ended at 1:30, but then it keeps going, repeating a phrase which to me seemed a little redundant. But that's just my 2¢. Thanks for sharing! P.S.: Please consider leaving a ❤️ or a 🏆 reaction for the people (including myself) who have gone through the trouble and donated their time to review your music. It really helps us feel appreciated and keeps the forum a healthy place for people to share! Thank you!

Hey @ferrum.wav! Great whimsical piano piece! It really feels organically conceived with a smooth and uninterrupted stream of musical consciousness! I think, pertaining to the above discussion about writing a piece completely without any variations, I think that's really difficult. One of the biggest determinants of whether a melodic piece is going to entertain the listener and stay in the musical consciousness is the constant interplay between unity and variety. For this reason it's always really hard (especially for me) to write music in a through-composed form. I always want to return to some kind of variation (at least) of the main theme. This brings both unity and variety at the same time. The only problem is that sometimes I write pieces where the variations aren't different enough from each other and so they don't bring enough variety and hence sound boring! (LoL) On the other hand, if there's too much variety then the piece could start to sound nonsensical to the listener, like the piece lacks thematic/motivic associations and hence doesn't build up a bank of memorable musical moments (unity). I really love how the piece feels like you improvised it - you really have a unique musical style that comes through here - it sounds like a fantasia. I've listened to it multiple times while writing this review and I've enjoyed every minute of it! Great job and thanks for sharing!

Hi all! It's officially October, which means it's time for some spooky songs. Almost each year I challenge myself to make a new arrangement of John Carpenter's classic theme from Halloween. It's always been one of my absolute favorite horror films, so it's truly a great joy to jump into this main theme and make it my own in composing. Would love to hear some feedback! I have tried a few new things in this song as I continue to experiment with techniques. I used mostly Native Instruments - Symphony Series, with support from Spitfire Audio's Originals Cinematic Soft Piano. Hope you enjoy the listen!

Thank you so much for all the kind words! Writing sheet music is something I am working on! I learned to compose using DAW software, so it doesn't always export the way I've written it to be in the DAW when using that. I do want to learn that side of things though. So glad you enjoyed the listen!

Been experimenting with this & trying to reharmonize the material, so it doesn't become so redundant. However, I'm not in love with that Eb bass Joe there.

Not much to say in critique of this work. Very Neo-Classical and elegant 🙂 Awesome work. I'd love to see this performed live!

Nice work! Just have one notational point. The staff for the soloists part in a concerto, should always be positioned directly above the 1st violins (see attached image).

This is a poll to first determine what the competition will be about. Once everyone votes (after a week - the poll closes October 8th) we'll make an official competition announcement and you'll be able to reply to that post to declare your intent to join the competition. Glad to hear you're onboard!

how do I enter?

Found this track from Gundam Wing Endless Duel - Port in a Super Mario World rom hack race level!

Changed the number of warning points which will result in each type of penalty.

Have now listened to Steven Stucky's arrangement of this work from 1991, and was pleased to discover it's very different from mine! He uses less woodwind, and more brass, with a far more radical reimagining of the original material (especially towards the end). Also interesting use of tubular bells that totally caught me by surprise! It's a far more accomplished piece of orchestral writing; but I feel like mine is more faithful to the original intention of the work. Anyway I'll let you be the judge.

Anyways, thanks for the feedback.

I thought scherzo meant joke in italian... I planned the notes very exactly too, just saying.

Added more content to the post about specifically what kind of penalties will be enacted.

Allllright.... Interesting. As far as I remember from College, and from my years as a trumpeter prior to that, "scherzo" is usually defined as a piece with a light, playful, yet vigorous style. My interpretation of that doesn't quite arrive at the conclusion that it should be difficult to perform, or rather, in this case, appearing near impossible, or, that the notes are randomly chosen. No intent to insult you at all, I'm simply explaining my perception of this piece, coming from an educated and experienced point of view. I'd urge you to continue writing, but to truly step back and analyze what you've written before you finalize it. Compare it to other works as well, in terms of it's overall form and structure, as well as the shapes of your phrases within the music. I'm sure you'll come to find that there are things that you did not realize before, and that could be altered to create a piece of music that you can truly be overjoyed at! Thanks for sharing 🙂

Hi to all. Just wanted to post an orchestration I've attempted of Purcell's "Funeral Sentences". Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think this was originally written for SATB choir, with timpani and a quartet of trumpets. Here I've arranged the piece for full symphony orchestra. Not sure if it's been orchestrated like this before, but haven't heard any other versions in this instrumentation. I used an old midi file as the basis for my score: so some of the trills and drum rolls look a bit strange. Think they sound more realistic like this though: so it may not be such a bad thing. Haven't bothered with slurs, as the score is designed for midi rendition only. (Also have noticed I need to correct my spelling of D major chords.) Hope you enjoy!

That is exactly why it is a scherzo.

Mr. Tristan... 😅😅 Piggy-backing off of what Henry said; I'd urge you to use the visualizer tool that Musescore.com has built into their interactive score window. Here's a screenshot of your piece in the visualizer. Idk about you, but that appears to be quite... inhuman to play. 😅😅😅 Almost like the notes written weren't chosen with any rhyme or reason. I look forward to seeing what you come up with in the future. Take your time, and really discover what it is that you want to "say" with your music!

Ah, I understand now! And don't take my words as judgement of your skill, at all. I hope that wasn't what was gathered. I didn't know this was written so long ago! Figured this was a newer score being shared as recent work looking for improvement. Thank you for the clarification.

Thank you so much again for your nice words. Im doing my best and making the music that express myself. Thanks again .

.