January 22, 200917 yr This is my first piano piece. It's kind of melancholic, kind of Sunday . This is just my hobby... Please listen to it, and comment is more then welcome. Sunday Thanks
January 22, 200917 yr The left hand gets very boring very quickly. Nice melody, but you gotta vary it up some. And the same chord progression over and over is also very boring.
January 23, 200917 yr Welcome to YC For incidental music this is perfect. It is not overpowering but its presence is known. If you want people here to comment on your music, it always helps to comment on some of theirs. Some will return the favor, (as it should be) while others are either too busy or too lame to take the few seconds required to type in a response. In time you will learn who will return the favor and who will not. Hope that helps Ron
January 24, 200917 yr Author Justin Tokke, thanks for your time, and for comment as well. On one side, I do agree with you, but on the other I decided to leave it like it is, as this is my very first composition. Clean and minimal :toothygrin:. Again, thanks.
January 24, 200917 yr Author Ron, thank you so much for advise, and comments as well. I am not very ambitious, though. I just decided not to be shy anymore and share my little musical creations with other humans :)... My focus is on story telling and emotions. The way I think (in musical way) might be interesting (not just boring) for musicians, since it's not burdened with rules and musical theory. ;)
January 24, 200917 yr It would fit perfectly well in a motion picture as the main theme or something. I liked it, it's very dramatic. However, I don't think the video has much to do with it. I thought of something a bit less coloured and more reflexive or imaginative. But the piece is great, good job! Pedro
January 24, 200917 yr Cannot but agree with justin Tokke ... melody is good, although some variation could be appreciated, yet.... the base line is very monotonous with the same chord heard over and over again. For a first attempt at composing a very good job that is true.
January 25, 200917 yr I too agree with Justin. But I must say it's very impressive for a first composition. Maybe you can take in the advice given on your future projects.
January 27, 200917 yr Author I too agree with Justin. But I must say it's very impressive for a first composition. Maybe you can take in the advice given on your future projects. Sure I will. Thanks
January 27, 200917 yr Author It would fit perfectly well in a motion picture as the main theme or something. I liked it, it's very dramatic. However, I don't think the video has much to do with it. I thought of something a bit less coloured and more reflexive or imaginative.But the piece is great, good job! Pedro Thank you Pedro. It's not made for that video :).
January 27, 200917 yr Author Cannot but agree with justin Tokke ... melody is good, although some variation could be appreciated, yet.... the base line is very monotonous with the same chord heard over and over again. For a first attempt at composing a very good job that is true. Thanks for your time. Agree. :thumbsup:
January 27, 200917 yr Very romantic... opening is reminiscent of Beethovens moonlight (very nice, i think). I think the repetitiveness of the material is actually a good thing in this instance.. and works well to ensure the overall feel of the piece. Very good work!
January 27, 200917 yr Ahoj Miljan, si Slovak alebo Cech? Alebo hovoris slovensky/cesky? Kde teraz zijes? Este raz dakujem za prekrasnu skladbu. S pozdravom Filipp. ps: I think we should keep conversation in English.
January 27, 200917 yr Author Very romantic... opening is reminiscent of Beethovens moonlight (very nice, i think). I think the repetitiveness of the material is actually a good thing in this instance.. and works well to ensure the overall feel of the piece. Very good work! Well, I'm so glad that you really felt it... Thanks jawoodruff. You made my day :). Miljan
February 2, 200917 yr It was good sir. About half way through kind of had me dazing a little. I'm sorry I didn't watch the whole video, but I think your chord progressions should change out of that main one IMO. Lets hear some more! :)
February 6, 200917 yr Has a neat prestigious feel to it, love it. The video is really fitting as well!
February 11, 200917 yr Nice job! I can see this music being used for a documentary about someone's life or showing some old black/white reels (say WWII). Personally, I would liked to have seen a change of key (modulation), at some point, but the variations make up for it.
February 13, 200917 yr Author Nice job! I can see this music being used for a documentary about someone's life or showing some old black/white reels (say WWII).Personally, I would liked to have seen a change of key (modulation), at some point, but the variations make up for it. You got that right. It is background music, ambiental. Thanks!
February 13, 200917 yr Hey, I really enjoyed this. As has been pointed out, it does get a tad repetitive, but for a first composition I don't think it really matters, you can only get better. I hope you keep it up, I look forward to future pieces :) Lex.
February 15, 200917 yr Author Hey, I really enjoyed this. As has been pointed out, it does get a tad repetitive, but for a first composition I don't think it really matters, you can only get better. I hope you keep it up, I look forward to future pieces :) Lex. Thanks man. I'll finish my other piece soon... Hopefully you'll like it. Miljan