Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Young Composers Music Forum

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

The July 2012 Monthly Competition

Featured Replies

Here it is folks, the YC CHOICE COMPETITION.

Let's go.

July 5th at midnight to July 31st at midnight.

Judging from August 1st-9th.

Results announced on the 10th.

The Premise: The Composer will take any work of Art (defined as something 2 dimensional and creatively constructed to BE art. You may only use works that are not created by your own hands or mind. You may use works not in a museum or anything, but a link to an image or the image itself MUST be provided in the submission thread) OR literature (defined as any book or short story or quotation or paragraph or really ANY written word of ANY length. You muse submit a summary or a link TO this work. Remember, if it is a work the Judges do not know, it could be more difficult to judge accurately the representation of inspiration, which will be counted in the points. A suggestion, then, is to provide a GOOD summary or a short passage the judges could work with) and set a piece of music that was inspired by it. You don't necessarily have to do a whole work, either. You could be inspired by a passage from the book. Or, you might like an Einstein quotation and set it. Or, a Dalai Lama quotation. As long as you submit something that was written down by somebody, you are good. That includes art. Computer generated art, for this particular competition, will be excluded. Computer generated writing, will not be excluded. The techniques are more or less the same.

The Point: Please make a work of art from a work of art. This is called a "derivative work", and is a very important part of an artist's development. All do this, whether they realize it or not. They steal from those they admire to make their own style. Or, they don't. But, most composers will take something from somebody else. In essence, nothing is intrinsic in art. I am asking you to take this and go with it with a conscious mind.

You MUST USE acoustic instruments. But, there is no limit to the number of instruments you may use. In fact, you MUST use more than 5 different TYPES of instruments. So, 5 cellos won't cut it. But, 2 violins, 1 viola, 1 cello, 1 double bass, and a piano would.

The Points:

Capturing the essence of the Source Material: /30

Score neatness and clarity: /10

Instrumentation (do you use the right number of instruments? use more than 5 different types. All must be acoustic (organs still count, a live synthesizer would work as well. But, a digitally implemented synthesizer is not allowed): /10

Orchestration (How well do you use the large ensemble together? The more work you put into this, the more points you will get. This is not a category that you will lose points from the maximum, but rather... this is a category where you must EARN the points): /20

Creativity (this is where doing cliche things will get you points taken off. Don't do a love story and just go with the characteristic romantic moods. Do something different or out there that garners the same effect): /10

Musicality (is your piece a PIECE of music? Does it have a good beginning, development, and end? is it stagnant? What gives it its identity? Write about the musicality in A PARAGRAPH of 200 words. Make sure it matches what you wrote too. This is about awareness of your music. Does it do what you want it to do?): /20

Participants:

1. Austenite

2. WilliamJeffrey

3. joshm222

4. theviolinist7

5. ad hoc

6. muhmuhmuhmusic

7. jsands

8. MaqamDjinn

9. NathanHathawayAdams

10. Bachian

11. ImperialFlute

12. OpusOneTwo7

13. Joshua Harton

14. MaestroWick

15. Piano18

16. PianoForte

17. ChristianPerrotta

I'll expect a minimum of 9. Since 9 people voted for it. But, more are definitely welcome UP TO 18 people. After that,the waiting list principle applies.

JUDGES:

1. TreeHugger1995

2. Morivou (I haven't judged in a while. :P)

3. Tokke

4.

Edited by Morivou
Double inclusion of a participant; fixed

  • Replies 180
  • Views 31.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • NathanHathawayAdams You did a fine job telling the general story. Unfortunately, I have never fulfilled ultimate nerdiness and I don't know all my superheros, sad childhood? I know :( so I don't know

  • Well this set of entries were, on the whole, very good stuff, so it required a lot of time to review everything thoroughly. Thanks to everyone for their patience!

  • Winds and Brass aren't acoustic instruments now?

I'm setting the example. As long as there is no catastrophe, count me in.

  • Author

Excellent. :) It's a fairly easy concept.

I'll participate.

I'd like in on this one.

I'll do it. Is literature considered an art?

  • Author

"OR literature" yeah. It's in the paragraph.

I'd love to join up, sounds good.

One clarification: what about sculpture? Could that be considered art, despite its third dimension?

  • Author

Nah. Sorry. 2 dimensions ONLY for this comp.

I'll join in too, but I won't start until 've got the time, and, since I am notoriously slow at composing, I may have to drop out later i!f I don't think I can finish in time.

The game is afoot!

Is there a time limit on length of the composition?

I'd like to participate. It will give me a good excuse to get a new composition out of the refrigerator and into the oven. ;)

Can I get a clarification on "computer generated art?"

To me (my trade is digital art and graphics), that term means something created by plotting vectors in a 3D program using math--generated by a computer-- and is completely different from a digital painting--something drawn or painted by hand, but with a stylus and tablet instead of pencil and paper/paint/etc.

Is the contest asking for Traditional art (created in a tangible medium) and prohibiting Digital art (exists originally on a screen)?

  • Author

Correct, ad hoc. Traditional Art only.

theviolinist7 - Not this time, no. :)

Ok, I'll do it. 2D traditional only, check.

ok. 30 minute tone poem here I come.

not really

I'm in.

Throughout July I am on vacation so I won't participate in any way. Good luck to everybody!

Unfortunately, I will join a festival this month beginning at next week, so I think I will not enter this one. But, maybe this change if I compose until 11th.

I'll give it a try, if you'll have me.

Hey, hey, hey. I told you before the decision I wanted in. Put me up there!!!!!!!!! XD

One more question. Is this Orchestra? Or Symphony?

  • Author

IF, in terms of instrumentation, please use more than 5 different named instruments.

In terms of form, whatever you'd like.

ooooh cool!!!!! BEST COMPETITION EVERRR!

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.