January 15Jan 15 87053bd8f2cb48d184ee054407d37bb8.mp3 Ā Any and all feedback is greatly appreciated. Please note that some of the grace notes are written like they are due to a better playback performance. Any advice on what the genre is? When it was just the first piece it was a Bagatelle, but now Iām not sure
January 16Jan 16 This is bright and fresh throughout, and plenty imaginative.Ā If you ask me, this feels like a Sonatina.Ā Ā In the first movement, you give the oom-pa-pa a break just in time before it get gets monotonous - even Viennese waltzes break this rhythmic figure occasionally.Ā I'm guessing that staying close to the tonic key is part of your style, but I think both movements could use more modulation to other keys in the course of the piece to freshen to tonal palate.Ā Also, the first chord in the left hand of the very last measure is strange to me...consider making it an octave D instead of A.Ā It will solidify the finality of the ending.Ā Ā Good job!
January 16Jan 16 I also find it to be a very imaginative piece that maintains a great deal of expressive coherence in terms of motifs and developments.
January 17Jan 17 Hi @Alant, The chord progression sounds familiar but this one is quite interesting to listen to when you use different variation techniques. Just beware of some playability issues: the left hand passage in b.136-137 is barely playable and the constant 32nd notes at the end for the right hand would be quite difficult and exhausting to play. Thx for sharing. Henry
January 18Jan 18 Author On 1/16/2026 at 4:16 AM, J. Lee Graham said: This is bright and fresh throughout, and plenty imaginative.Ā If you ask me, this feels like a Sonatina.Ā Ā In the first movement, you give the oom-pa-pa a break just in time before it get gets monotonous - even Viennese waltzes break this rhythmic figure occasionally.Ā I'm guessing that staying close to the tonic key is part of your style, but I think both movements could use more modulation to other keys in the course of the piece to freshen to tonal palate.Ā Also, the first chord in the left hand of the very last measure is strange to me...consider making it an octave D instead of A.Ā It will solidify the finality of the ending.Ā Ā Good job! Ā I donāt have an aversion to modulations I just donāt have much experience with them. Were there any parts you thought could use it specifically? I was thinking maybe around 1:00 and 2:45 (measures 41 and 126)
January 18Jan 18 2 hours ago, Alant said: I was thinking maybe around 1:00 and 2:45 (measures 41 and 126) Yeah, like the two places you quoted, b.41 can be modulated to G major with the constant Mixolydian C natural throughout the piece, and D minor in b.126!
January 19Jan 19 This sounds like an interesting and inventive subversion of a waltz.Ā I'm curious why you describe it as two movements, though.Ā I guess you're considering a new movement to start at m. 106, but it's in the same tempo and style. Also, you probably know this, but the stuff in the right hand at m. 158 and forward would normally be written as tremolos.Ā I assume you wrote out the notes so that the notation software played it back correctly, but in such cases I'll usually prepare separate versions of the score for playback and for display.
January 23Jan 23 On 1/18/2026 at 2:22 PM, Alant said: I donāt have an aversion to modulations I just donāt have much experience with them. Were there any parts you thought could use it specifically? I was thinking maybe around 1:00 and 2:45 (measures 41 and 126) @AlantĀ Both of those spots would be excellent, especially 41.Ā Ā
January 26Jan 26 This is aĀ charming and very imaginative work.Ā To my ear it's a bit Jazzy with a Gerhwinesque flavor.Ā It was delightful to hear.Ā Ā Mark
January 31Jan 31 Author I have a question about dictation. Iād like the melody that appears 25 seconds in Ā (measure 17) to have a more ājumpyā rhythm. This is the audio of how I want it to sound. Basically some parts (like measure 19) are little quicker and come in a little earlier. Is there a way I can write this in the sheet music? Any help is appreciated.
Saturday at 03:57 PM4 days Author On 1/18/2026 at 4:34 PM, Henry Ng Tsz Kiu said: Yeah, like the two places you quoted, b.41 can be modulated to G major with the constant Mixolydian C natural throughout the piece, and D minor in b.126! Ā Can you clarify what you mean by āconstant mixolydian C natural throughout the pieceā? It goes over my head, do you mean stay in G major and go back at b.126?
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.