November 7Nov 7 Nocturne- E minor.mp3Nocturne- E minor.pdfHello.Recently finished this piece and felt it was something interesting to share;What i feel makes this piece distinct is that its quite heavily harmonically driven, as in the melody doesn't stray far from the current harmonic background; I'm quite satisfied with the structure, as i feel it keeps the piece interesting and fresh all the way through;I'm still not sure if i should say this piece is in E minor, as its never really suggested until the very end.(also this piece used to have a subtitle in early stages, but as i was composing further on it didn't quite stick, so some ideas of what to call it would be nice)Thoughts and feedback are always welcome.Enjoy the music.
November 7Nov 7 Hello.I listened to your Nocturne. The piece is very interesting in its musical language, and it is well constructed in terms of form.However, it seems to me that this music belongs to the category of works that look clearer and more understandable on paper than they sound. Both in the accompaniment and in the melodic line you use very wide leaps and cover a very large range. For this reason, without the score it’s not always possible to tell where the accompaniment is and where the main figure is. The pulsation in groups of nine also feels somewhat intrusive. But that is probably more a problem of computer playback. A live pianist would most likely play more softly, and that pulsation wouldn’t draw so much attention.In any case, it’s good, interesting music.
November 11Nov 11 I really like how the piece patiently unfolds it's texture and content without trying force it's melody out so strikingly against the accompaniment, rather they compliment one another to create that moodiness, the erraticness sounds natural rather than abrupt...The continous motions of the accompaniment make the pauses in the ending measure and the ending feel well-earned rather than just reached.
Monday at 04:03 PM3 days Hello islav, thank you for sharing this — I listened and followed the score, and I was struck by how patiently the piece unfolds. The opening is especially effective: the right hand waits through the first bar, then answers with that high descending figure and fermata in bars 2–3, while the left hand keeps the nine-note groups moving underneath in 9/8. That contrast between the still, singing line and the continuous accompaniment gives the harmony room to shift without the melody ever having to hurry, and holding E minor back until the very end makes the arrival feel earned. One suggestion: because those wide leaps in both hands can blur which line is the melody, you could try thinning the accompaniment slightly or softening the lower nine-note groups where the right-hand line is at its highest, so the singing line stays in front. For a subtitle, something like “Nocturne — After Rain” or “Nocturne — Late Light” might suit that quiet, harmonically driven mood. Do you hear the piece as a single nocturne, or as the start of a set of short night pieces?
2 hours ago2 hr Author On 11/16/2026 at 9:03 PM, Ali Baghbani said:Hello islav, thank you for sharing this — I listened and followed the score, and I was struck by how patiently the piece unfolds. The opening is especially effective: the right hand waits through the first bar, then answers with that high descending figure and fermata in bars 2–3, while the left hand keeps the nine-note groups moving underneath in 9/8. That contrast between the still, singing line and the continuous accompaniment gives the harmony room to shift without the melody ever having to hurry, and holding E minor back until the very end makes the arrival feel earned. One suggestion: because those wide leaps in both hands can blur which line is the melody, you could try thinning the accompaniment slightly or softening the lower nine-note groups where the right-hand line is at its highest, so the singing line stays in front. For a subtitle, something like “Nocturne — After Rain” or “Nocturne — Late Light” might suit that quiet, harmonically driven mood. Do you hear the piece as a single nocturne, or as the start of a set of short night pieces?Hirelating to your subtitle suggestions, a bit too on the nose for me, i like more abstract titles, to leave the exact imagery open to interpretation. but i appreciate the thought.And no i don't really hear any of my music as parts of a potential collection, just a bunch of stand alone character pieces and ideas.Thank you for your feedback and thoughts
57 minutes ago57 min Thank you, islav — that makes complete sense, and I appreciate you explaining it. Leaving the title abstract fits the piece well, since the harmony does so much of the work and the melody stays close to it, and the high descending figure with the fermata in bars 2-3 already gives the listener plenty to imagine without a picture in the title. I also like hearing them as standalone character pieces — each one can keep its own mood that way. Do you have another standalone piece in mind already, or are you letting the next idea arrive on its own?
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.