Sunday at 08:30 PM3 days Welcome all.Here is my attempt to orchestrate a lament from Bach's BWV992 keyboard suite.The original is mostly one and two part material: so I had to invent several new counterpoint lines; otherwise the orchestration sounded too thin.I'm currently working on the other movements.Wonder if you think my added counterpoint is successful?The suite was suggested by an AI, when I asked which work by Bach was crying out to be orchestrated, where no prior orchestral arrangements exist.I know there are lots of note-stalks pointing in the wrong direction, as well as missing a2 directions, and missing slurs; but can you see any other problems?Bach - Capriccio (BWV 992) #8 (partial).mp3Bach - Capriccio (BWV 992) #8 (partial).pdf Edited Sunday at 10:56 PM3 days by Alex Weidmann
3 minutes ago3 min HelloI love the way it sounds.I can’t remember the original – I’d have to listen to it again to compare – but I don’t need to, as it works really well for me just as it is.I don’t know which parts have been added, but as it all sounds very cohesive, I don’t mind.I think that when you orchestrate something, you can be very, very literal or the complete opposite; the important thing is to do it with flair or with a purpose.The chromatic descents sound phenomenal. The oboe with the muted trumpet is a combination that might seem a bit odd at first, but when the trumpet is muted, they blend together beautifully.When the full string section comes in on bar 34 – although it’s not exactly the same, even in terms of instrumental density – it reminded me of Wagner, or Maher. Perhaps because of the chromaticism present. What a crazy but intriguing idea – Bach-Wagner. I’m sure Wagner studied Bach.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.