Sunday at 08:30 PM5 days Welcome all.Here is my attempt to orchestrate a lament from Bach's BWV992 keyboard suite.The original is mostly one and two part material: so I had to invent several new counterpoint lines; otherwise the orchestration sounded too thin.I'm currently working on the other movements.Wonder if you think my added counterpoint is successful?The suite was suggested by an AI, when I asked which work by Bach was crying out to be orchestrated, where no prior orchestral arrangements exist.I know there are lots of note-stalks pointing in the wrong direction, as well as missing a2 directions, and missing slurs; but can you see any other problems?Bach - Capriccio (BWV 992) #8 (partial).mp3Bach - Capriccio (BWV 992) #8 (partial).pdf Edited Sunday at 10:56 PM5 days by Alex Weidmann
Yesterday at 06:20 PM1 day HelloI love the way it sounds.I can’t remember the original – I’d have to listen to it again to compare – but I don’t need to, as it works really well for me just as it is.I don’t know which parts have been added, but as it all sounds very cohesive, I don’t mind.I think that when you orchestrate something, you can be very, very literal or the complete opposite; the important thing is to do it with flair or with a purpose.The chromatic descents sound phenomenal. The oboe with the muted trumpet is a combination that might seem a bit odd at first, but when the trumpet is muted, they blend together beautifully.When the full string section comes in on bar 34 – although it’s not exactly the same, even in terms of instrumental density – it reminded me of Wagner, or Maher. Perhaps because of the chromaticism present. What a crazy but intriguing idea – Bach-Wagner. I’m sure Wagner studied Bach.
5 hours ago5 hr Author 22 hours ago, Luis Hernández said:HelloI love the way it sounds.I can’t remember the original – I’d have to listen to it again to compare – but I don’t need to, as it works really well for me just as it is.I don’t know which parts have been added, but as it all sounds very cohesive, I don’t mind.I think that when you orchestrate something, you can be very, very literal or the complete opposite; the important thing is to do it with flair or with a purpose.The chromatic descents sound phenomenal. The oboe with the muted trumpet is a combination that might seem a bit odd at first, but when the trumpet is muted, they blend together beautifully.When the full string section comes in on bar 34 – although it’s not exactly the same, even in terms of instrumental density – it reminded me of Wagner, or Maher. Perhaps because of the chromaticism present. What a crazy but intriguing idea – Bach-Wagner. I’m sure Wagner studied Bach.Thanks Luis.I was aiming for a Late Romantic interpretation, rather like Busoni's Bach transcriptions. So I'm delighted you can hear echoes of Wagner and Mahler!You can listen to the original in the You Tube video linked below, starting at 3'17". (I chose to ignore the figured bass in this version, because I'm not sure where it comes from.) Edited 5 hours ago5 hr by Alex Weidmann
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.