18 hours ago18 hr Hello, I am a novice composer and this is my first post on this forum, which I discovered by accident today. This forum is just what I'm looking for, a place to share my compositions to others other than YouTube. I haven't got a lot of experience in composing or orchestration, so please take this in mind. Any constructive criticism would be welcome. I also have a YouTube channel where I upload my compositions: https://www.youtube.com/@tylerplayspiano-2026 video-score_sinfoniettamscx.mp3 video-score_sinfonietta-2mscx.mp3 video-score_sinfonietta-3mscx.mp3
14 minutes ago14 min HelloI’ve listened to Part 1 on YouTube, because I like to look at the score.Your ideas are very good, but I think there are a few things to consider in terms of orchestration.I’m no expert, but that’s my opinion.The opening catches the ear because I don’t think those pp dynamics up there on the flute are feasible.The clarinets are playing figures that are typical of the piano – not very idiomatic – but, what’s more, with no rest for so many bars, they need to catch their breath.Another thing I’ve noticed is those very long notes that form the harmony; they don’t sound right on these instruments. The harmonic foundation needs to move; in fact, in an orchestra, everything has to be alive.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.