Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Young Composers Music Forum

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

All Activity

This stream auto-updates

  1. Today

  2. i thinking for prelude now.
  3. Yesterday

  4. Dear @Forty6 I'm really glad you appreciated the piece! Believe it or not, I had never heard the "Space Song" by Beach House, it was completely unknown to me. However, I think I can understand why you see a similarity: the kind of synth patches, the very beginning of the theme and the overall ambiance. In my case, I just had some fun with the Bit 99. Many appreciate it for the Italo Disco vibe, but I tend to prefer atmospheric and airy timbres. I have another space-inspired piece of music written mainly for the Bit 99 that I will post in a few days. It took maybe two or three days of my spare time to put together the chords and the melody, then one week to polish everything. In general I work with successive approximations: the first piece is quite rough, then I try to improve it until I reach a point where I cannot improve it anymore. This does not mean that there is no margin for improvement, of course and I am always glad to receive suggestions and impressions about things that can be done better. There are some deliberate choices though (the limited use of compressors and the catchy theme is not heard until a certain point in the piece).
  5. Egor Ukoloff joined the community
  6. I think that before answering the question of whether the repetition of the subject is a disadvantage, because that's what I think DAI initially posed, we have to answer whether the tonal difference is a differentiating factor in itself. I believe that DAI has not understood that each note is composed of a different frequency and that each frequency has a different effect on its recipient. What does this mean? This means that the same melody played in two different tones, e.g. A major and C major, does not have the same effect on the listener and therefore they are two different things and therefore we cannot talk about repetitiveness, so the original question of DAI is incorrect in itself. Changing from F major to B major changes the actual frequencies, even if the melody’s interval pattern stays the same. In equal temperament, B is six semitones above F in the same octave, about, √2, times its frequency. That can change the sound’s perceived color and how an instrument resonates. How many people, do you thing, will answer the question : "do you think green is sad or happy color" ,with "sad", except of those who have connected green with a sad fact happened in their life ? The proof of what I am arguing is that composers, often, choose specific tones in which they expose and develop their themes depending on how dark or light etc, they want to give. Jawoodruff has already referred to this by, correctly, saying : "You're a composer... make waves", associating sounds with frequencies. Also, he may have guessed, correctly, by addressing DAI saying : "I think you've just not really heard that many fugues". That's why I'm quoting here, if you will allow me, three modern fugues for DAI to listen to, so that he can have a more complete view, but after first understanding that it is a matter of waves-frequencies. Three modern Fugues : https://youtu.be/nErluwSIn0o
  7. kraka started following Repetitive Fugue
  8. Yes, you’re right, this music is intended for a professional orchestra. I was aiming at the level of an average symphony orchestra that plays the standard repertoire of classical concerts: symphonies, overtures, tone poems... Of course, wherever possible, I tried to avoid unjustified difficulties. But the very character of this music pushes toward complexity. The tempo, the syncopated rhythms, the asymmetrical meters (like 7/8) create the image, but they also give the musicians a hard time. Thank you for the positive feedback. I’m very glad that people enjoy my musical illustrations :)
  9. I completely see the fusion haha It's all so bouncy, it carries a momentum that holds you in your seat for its entirety and I love the trombone that comes in at 0:33, I don't even know how to describe the feeling I get when I listen to this, while at first that it seems like it's a very dancy, bouncy kind of carnival song, then it sounds like it's more witty in a way (again, I have no idea how to describe it...) Anyways, great job!
  10. My only comment is on the skill level of the work for musicians. At your tempos you would need an orchestra of highly skilled -if not professional musicians. I initially thought this would be a fun work for the community orchestras I play in; however, I don't know if they have the skill the work requires. It is a FUN work! Mark
  11. I am so very very pleased you enjoyed "The Door Opens". It took me an entire afternoon to settle on a title! I am fortunate to play in a few orchestras these last 39 years ... it provides me an intimate aural setting. This I believe helps my orchestrations .... 🙂 Can't help but hear it all from Bach to Prokofiev to Copland. It's very different playing amidst all the wonderful sonorities than just listening. Mark
  12. Hello Tristan, thank you for sharing the reworked version — I listened and followed the score, and I enjoyed hearing how the piece has moved away from its waltz origins into something freer. The opening works well: in 3/4 at Moderato, the right hand's singing line sits clearly over the left hand's chordal accompaniment, and the little triplet turn in bar 4 gives the melody a gentle lift before the rising arpeggiated figures in bars 6–8 open it out into a longer, flowing phrase. That contrast between the song-like opening and the more rhapsodic, free-flowing middle is what gives the piece its character. One suggestion, echoing Mark's comment: the opening theme is so memorable that I wanted to hear it return or develop more later on, so you could try bringing a varied form of it back near the end, perhaps in a different register or with a fuller left-hand texture, to tie the rhapsody together. Did the reworking change the ending as well, or did the free-form middle grow out of the original waltz ending?
  13. Hello islav, thank you for sharing this — I listened and followed the score, and I was struck by how patiently the piece unfolds. The opening is especially effective: the right hand waits through the first bar, then answers with that high descending figure and fermata in bars 2–3, while the left hand keeps the nine-note groups moving underneath in 9/8. That contrast between the still, singing line and the continuous accompaniment gives the harmony room to shift without the melody ever having to hurry, and holding E minor back until the very end makes the arrival feel earned. One suggestion: because those wide leaps in both hands can blur which line is the melody, you could try thinning the accompaniment slightly or softening the lower nine-note groups where the right-hand line is at its highest, so the singing line stays in front. For a subtitle, something like “Nocturne — After Rain” or “Nocturne — Late Light” might suit that quiet, harmonically driven mood. Do you hear the piece as a single nocturne, or as the start of a set of short night pieces?
  14. Thank you for your kind reply, Laurent, and best wishes to you in France as well. I am glad the balance between the piano and the bass clarinet came across, especially that opening where the piano's repeated pattern keeps moving while the clarinet enters with its low, warm line. Do you have another piece for this combination in mind, or are you planning to explore a different pairing next?
  15. You are very welcome, Martynas — I am glad the comments were useful. Your minuet stayed with me because that light staccato opening in 3/4 and the warm B-section contrast from bar 16 give it such a clear, dance-like character. Are you planning to write another dance movement to pair with it, or to develop the B-section material further in a longer piece?
  16. Thank you for such an interesting review. As for the “cosmic” sound, you are largely right. This movement contains images of the otherworldly, or rather, hints of them. Vika Osadchenko, the poet whose poems this suite is based on, wrote the lines that formed the basis of this movement shortly after the death of her mother. Below, I asked Claude (an AI) to translate the poem into English so that you can understand what it is about. if only I could remember how to pass through these doors if only I could remember where the little boat to the other shore is what to say and where to put the coin was it thrown into the river, for remembrance or something It spins, it spins, the little planet. See, there is as much darkness as light? It’s not frightening at all to fall. the milky eternal path is dimly familiar it spins it spins somewhere morning will come the body autumn leaves, see-through blown away somewhere by a gentle cold wind See, there is as much hope as not-knowing. Whatever may happen to us in this life, see, we are always on the border of light?
  17. "If you've listened to the pieces I've shared here, you've probably noticed that I like working across different styles and aren't afraid to experiment. Some of my experiments might even seem a bit vulgar to certain listeners, but my credo is... don't repeat yourself, try to discover something new, and above all—music should essentially be beautiful (though this last part is just my personal take)."
  18. floraplant joined the community
  19. Last week

  20. Welcome all. Here is my attempt to orchestrate a lament from Bach's BWV992 keyboard suite. The original is mostly one and two part material: so I had to invent several new counterpoint lines; otherwise the orchestration sounded too thin. I'm currently working on the other movements. Wonder if you think my added counterpoint is successful? The suite was suggested by an AI, when I asked which work by Bach was crying out to be orchestrated, where no prior orchestral arrangements exist. I know there are lots of note-stalks pointing in the wrong direction, as well as missing a2 directions, and missing slurs; but can you see any other problems? Bach - Capriccio (BWV 992) #8 (partial).mp3 Bach - Capriccio (BWV 992) #8 (partial).pdf
  21. Thank you Ali for your message and your appreciation of the piece. Best wishes from France. Laurent
  22. Thank you for sharing this, Laurent — I listened to the recording and followed the score, and the shape of the piece stayed with me. I liked how the piano carries the first nine bars alone: that repeated, accented pattern at quarter note = 95, in 4/4 with three flats in the key signature, sets a quiet, restrained mood before the bass clarinet enters, so its entry feels like a voice joining a conversation already in progress. The bass clarinet's low, warm register suits the title beautifully, and I agree with Forty6 that the final clarinet phrase, with its triplet figure settling onto a long note in bar 58, gives the piece a satisfying, unhurried close. Your point about the contrast between the clarinet's melancholy resignation and the piano's agitation really does come across for me, especially in that opening — the piano keeps moving while the clarinet sings more simply above it. If I were developing it further, I would be tempted to let the piano thin out for a few bars when the clarinet holds its longest notes, just to give the bass clarinet even more air — but the balance as it stands already works well, and thank you for sharing such a thoughtful, well-notated piece.
  23. Thank you for sharing this — I listened to the recording and followed the score, and the opening of the A section really charmed me: the light, staccato melody in 3/4 over those steady chordal figures in the lower staff gives it a clear, dance-like lift, and the drop to piano with a crescendo in bars 3–4 is a lovely touch. I also enjoyed the contrast in the B section from bar 16, especially the longer running passage in bars 22–27 under the big slur, which builds nicely before the Vivace A material returns. If I could suggest one thing to explore, it would be varying the left-hand accompaniment pattern a little more in the return of A, so the reprise feels fresh rather than identical — but as it stands, it is a graceful, well-shaped little minuet.
  24. Here my minuet i would like for feedback Minuet in C.mp3 Minuet in C.pdf
  25. Thank you for your comment and your suggestion. I'm glad you enjoyed the piece! I suppose it's meant to be a slightly different take on sadness than usual: a contrast between the simple melancholy resignation of the clarinet and the agitation of the piano. I hope that comes across a bit nonetheless... Thanks again for taking the time to listen. Best wishes
  26. Mr.minor joined the community
  27. Hi Luis, Thank you very much for your words, I'm so glad you enjoyed the piece. I know what you mean about how it doesn't quite go in the direction suggested by the opening bars. It is a bit of an odd feeling, I agree, which sometimes I get and at others I don't so much, but I haven't yet quite managed to work out how it comes about. But the way the piano works towards these moments of agitation is central to the theme. About the clarinet, it sounds like a bass clarinet to me, with its somewhat hollow woody timbre, even on the high notes, which conveys a specific kind of sadness in contrast to the often agitated piano. But then again I was not there when it was recorded, so I can't be entirely sure... Thanks again for your comments. Best wishes
  28. Part III. I liked the opening, with the strings creating an almost ‘cosmic’ atmosphere (as in Lohengrin). The first exposition with vocals/text left me wanting a bit more, as the strings play a very passive accompanying role, with nothing more than long notes. But I noticed that in the recapitulation they take on a much more active role, so the contrast works well. Overall, I like the way you give the instruments such a prominent role, even though it’s a composition with text and vocals.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.