Leaderboard

Thank you very much. After reading yours and @MJFOBOE comment, I am going to study/listen to some music that is overtly pointillistic music so that I can immerse myself in that style more purposefully. Yes, the gospel choir joins right at the end. It was not planned beforehand. The idea just came to me at that moment. I could hear Amazing Grace in my head - and I did not not want to ignore what I could hear just because it wouldn't make immediate logical sense. If it came into my mind whilst composing, then I trust that it makes sense, somehow. Indeed, that they connect by being in the same key is merely a coincidence. If the two sections were in different keys, I would still be ok with it. "mostly quite enjoyable" makes me smile. (hopefully there is an added emphasis on the 'mostly!').

MP3 Play / pause Butterfly Net - Caroline Polachek 1:11 4:46 volume > next menu Butterfly Net - Caroline Polachek > next PDF Butterfly Net - Caroline Polachek That's a very lovely work.

Hey guys, a couple weeks ago I posted a study called "luscious" for string orchestra. Today I have it here as an expanded piece. The beginning is nearly the same, expect with an accelerando in the A'' section, so that when the A'' section appears at the end, it has more impact. There are many pieces of advice taken from others, importantly modulation. frankly, these are not fabulous examples of the modulation you have been asking for, as they don't don't happen on the climaxes of melodies, which does not come to me naturally. I'm working on another exercise which will hopefully do that in a convincing manner, however this was more of a brain itch than an effort to improve.

Thank you for giving it a listen and describing what you liked about it. It seems like you understood and appreciated my piece the most at the parts I also cared the most about. Thank you for listening! I appreciate your feedback from before, helping me get this piece right.

Hello @Aw Ke Shen! This piece held my interest much more consistently and really took the idea of repetition with variation to heart. I'm glad you're taking this avenue in your development and I'm enjoying it very much! I think there is still a spot where you sequence a certain figuration by walking up the scale step by step - for me that was still a bit predictable. But there are styles of music where more repetition or sequencing is expected such as minimalism. And there's ways of making that work if you want to explore that. Btw - I loved the canonic imitation between the right and left hands - a great example of repetition that enriches the listening experience because of a shift in the metric placement of the material. Thanks for sharing!

Hi, it was a bit of a challenge to categorize your style/work: impressionist - minimalist; however, I agree with the above insight as pointillist. I wonder what was your idea/purpose in integrating the choral work? By the way the orchestra has a wonderful texture/color. Mark

Hi @Symphonic! Very cool - pointillistic sometimes. There is definitely a recurring theme to this although it was quite unusual and disjointed. Or at least very fragmented/dissolute. I like also all the polyrhythms going at different rates. I was going to say - "but where's the gospel choir?" LoL But is this your own arrangement of Amazing Grace or a performance of someone else's arrangement? Either way the performance is quite good! You also don't really explain how the Palette piece is supposed to be connected/related to the Amazing Grace song. At the point at which they connect they're in the same key - at least that much is audible though. Overall this was mostly quite enjoyable! There were a few spots where I felt like you kept me as the listener waiting for something though. But other than that it was great! Thanks for sharing.

liked it very much. the only thing I hate is the mechanical computer-generated playback

I have a silly suggestion, but I guess this may work. You can download the song as an mp3 file using Youtube premium maybe.

Hey there First off, what a cool song 😄 I've never heard it before, but there was a lot of neat percussion stuff going on, like banging on things in the kitchen. She's got a great voice too. Nice mode mixture stuff, EDM effects in the bass, it's all great. Ever get the melody to work for the mp3? I use Sibelius unfortunately. What if you just copied the notes into a new file or something? I'm sure it's just a weird bug. What you have seems promising though. Looks like you emulated the guitar rhythm nicely with the string accompaniment. All the transcribing you did looks spot on