Jump to content

Piano Fantasia Competition


beautifulnoise

Recommended Posts

  • 2 weeks later...

SO, is this still judging or did it commit suicide?

It's still judging, sorry, I should have posted, considering that it is taking so long...

Tokkemon didn't get the original message I had sent with all the entries - Jimmyjuicin's computer has failed, they are both working on the scores now.

Judges, please finish your scoring by November 30th at Midnight!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The WannaBeChopin's Scoring.

Hehe, Hi. Lucky I went on to Young Composers today, :P Sorry for being so late. I am recovering from Swine Flu at the moment. :P

Micah- 76/100 I liked this a lot, however sometimes I felt it suddenly stopped, but maybe this was the desire effect. Now I can go all cadencial on you!! The piece didn't end with a cadence :sadtears:! Anyway, I thought this was a nice composition with nice ideas. I really liked how it flowed, but sometimes it just stopped, which I didn't really like. It didn't really capture the FANTASIA part of it, it was just a tad predictable.

Eric Darr- 69/100- Very "Nice" I did enjoy it. (But it didn't end with a cadence!) Although It was a bit higgle-ti-pigglety, (With the triplets.) I still didn't think it had the dramatic qualities of a Fantasia though.

PianoMan- 73/100 A Realy Fantasia I would say, although the start 3 chords with their varations did get slightly repetetive after a while. It was interesting putting them in two movements, a strange idea. Their wasn't really a tune in the first movement their was only this motiff of three chords which got rather repetetive. their was a glimmer of hope the second movement would turn out to be a nice slow bit to make into a true unpredictable fantasia but this didn't really happen. :P

Sethy- 65/100 Jazzy. :) Although not my taste it could be other people's taste. Again this piece did not really have a tune although the harmony was nice. And How long does this piece go on for? :o I Went away not realizing I left the piece on for twenty minute and it was still playing!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...