Chorale #1

It's pleasant. Alto has a bit of a weird part in m. 10, but it's unobtrusive.

Sounds Okay. Could you tell us about it? Is this one of Bach's chorales and if so which parts have you completed? 

Very nice. is there a function to this chorale? are you using it as a harmonic template for something later? 

Quick note, in measure 10 beat two you've double the G# note which is against traditional rules.

On 6/29/2020 at 2:22 PM, Monarcheon said:

It's pleasant. Alto has a bit of a weird part in m. 10, but it's unobtrusive.

 

I know it is a little weird, but I wen't for something that was more smooth than rather more correct.

On 7/1/2020 at 5:20 AM, Markus Boyd said:

Sounds Okay. Could you tell us about it? Is this one of Bach's chorales and if so which parts have you completed? 

 

It is not a Bach chorale, it is 100% mine.

On 7/1/2020 at 7:24 AM, Bradley Scarff said:

Very nice. is there a function to this chorale? are you using it as a harmonic template for something later? 

 

Quick note, in measure 10 beat two you've double the G# note which is against traditional rules.

 

Not really, I just made it so I could play it in real life. I'm terrible at the keyboard, so I made it easy for me.

Yes, i know that doubling the leading tone is against the rules, like I said earlier, I wen't for something that was more smooth than rather more correct.