Jesus was Born this Day

"Jesus was Born this Day," is a hymnal song that includes, Euouae.  Haven't heard the amen since the medieval times, thought I'd bring it back to present.

The chords are adventurous and don't make much sense.  However, this was the palette that I wanted for artificial intelligence to include.  AI, did pick up the tune very well, except for the Euouae that was wanted for Descant.  Anyone know how to do that in a prompt for AI?

I'm out of ideas, I even used the braille's "In accord," to get AI to pick up the command.

Other than that, the chorus was botched to good effect, read as the melody after a vowel chant.  In effect, AI made a new chorus.  Overall, the song is represented well, and I am happy with that.

Enjoy!

 

Jesus Was Born this Day_Harper.mid

Jesus Was Born this Day_Harper.mid Jesus Was Born on this Day (David Harper) - MSMT.mid

So what's the part in the "piece" that is composed by you but not generated by AI? If the part is small I doubt it should be counted as your entry.

Henry

Well, look at you Mr. PC.  My "AI Creation," really is 1:1 with my composition.  If you'd feel better with me being bullied out of the entry, by all means, so you may have more fun.

1 hour ago, Vonias said:

Well, look at you Mr. PC.  My "AI Creation," really is 1:1 with my composition.  If you'd feel better with me being bullied out of the entry, by all means, so you may have more fun.

Don't overact, I am just asking how much effort you put in your composition to consider it as your entry, because if someone just clicks a button and makes an entry, it will be unfair to other entrants who write their music 100%. So in your case it's 50% right?

Henry

The staff have discussed this issue and we have decided that we shouldn't allow AI-generated works into the event.  People who are going to try to get the "Ardent Reviewer" badge will be tasked with reviewing all the entries into the event and it would be unfair to require them to review an AI-generated work.  This is not bullying.

Right, but this isn't an AI generated work.  The score, and midi are my own.  It's an AI generated recording.

You generated the second score after the fact of the AI-recording.  So we don't know if the harmonies and melodies were generated by AI or by you because you could have simply generated them with the AI and then simply transcribed the result to get a score.

He's accusing me of just clicking a button to generate music.  I think you are missing the point here.  There was great effort in creating this piece.

If you're looking for reasons to exclude anyone during the holuday season, so be it.  Have a merry christmas.

Can you be clear as to what exactly is AI generated? I've used AI to create music using Suno, and it's never this harmonically intricate, not even close. Just clarify for us what role AI had in this piece.

12 hours ago, Vonias said:

Well, look at you Mr. PC.  My "AI Creation," really is 1:1 with my composition

I

What AI?

I am unaware of any AI currently on the market that is capable of rendering sheet music as high-quality, "1:1" audio. If there was already such a thing, the sample library market would have imploded.

But you said you "Prompted" it. Well, I'm similarly unaware of any of the major music AIs being able to deliver anything 1:1 based on a description. If such a thing existed, Suno and whatever the other big one is would already have been trounced. I tried to get these things to generate just a drone all by itself and it couldn't even do that, so I don't believe that, based on a prompt, you got an AI to deliver these complex harmonies and such "1:1"

Absolutely no way.

@Vonias - The staff have discussed this further and come to the following conclusions:

1)  The Christmas Music Event is not a competition and there are no rules so there was no prohibition at the outset against AI music being submitted (we will include such a prohibition in future competitions)
2)  Anybody trying to get an Ardent Reviewer badge should be warned that AI was used to help in the process of producing any given piece of music and @Vonias does mention this in his description.

Therefore we've decided to reinstate your piece in this years Christmas Music Event!

Thank you.