December 23, 200520 yr What do you consider to be the greatest (not your personal favorate) piece of music ever written?
December 28, 200520 yr Author This is a difficult question, because there are so many different types of musical composition. It is impossible to compare, say, a great violin concerto to a great piano solo and say which is "better". Instead, works of a similar type, such a symphonies, should be compared.
December 28, 200520 yr Don't tell me it's another mind invasion here. * grins * Heeehee.. :closedeyes: I'm tempted to say Grieg piano concerto in a minor, but no, Beethoven's emperor (piano conc no 5) is pure brilliance.
December 28, 200520 yr Greatest, well thats plain silly! Avro Part symphony n.2 or......... yah, I don't think you can really leave personal opinion out of this.
December 28, 200520 yr the music that had the most emotional impact on my was Mahler's first symphony
December 28, 200520 yr This is tough. What makes a piece great? Is it the asethic beauty it offers or the difficulty? Is the ability to be hum by all and be known for hundreds of years? It really is tough to guage. I'll get back to you on this
December 29, 200520 yr I have not yet heard the greatest piece of music ever written, if it even exists yet.
December 30, 200520 yr I enjoy the sound track to the movie Siamese Twins and the City of Angels sound track in a more classical vein. That said, the best music I've heard isn't written, it's mostly improvised on Afghani Rebab by Khaled Arman with tabla drum accompaniment. Gongchime
December 30, 200520 yr The concertos and symphonies of Mozart and Beethoven. I could say sonatas as well, but i want to keep the "greatest piece" to below 100 pieces....
December 31, 200520 yr greatest piece in the history of music: Mozart Requiem followed by Bach Mass B minor Cherubini Requiem Brahms German Requiem Beethoven Missa Solemnis Handel Messiah Yea can you tell I like masses and requiems? I really do consider that list the greatest music e'er writ though, and I consider choral polyphonic music to be the highest form of musical expression.
December 31, 200520 yr hm. what is cherubini's requiem like? Beethoven considered it to be greater than Mozart's.
December 31, 200520 yr Brahms, Berlioz and Schumann all considered Cherubini's requiem to be the greatest ever written and I've heard of various composers requesting it to be played at their funerals. I'd hardly ever even heard of Cherubini up until I kept reading various quotes about the composers I worship speaking of him like he was pretty immense. Beethoven flat out considered him "the greatest dramatic composer in all of Europe" (i.e. in the world) and in Brahms apartment at the time of his death he had only about 4 things famously adorning his wall, a Beethoven bust, a painting of Cherubini, and the emperor's portrait. I got interested and read up on him and ended up discovering he only wrote one or two things of great note although he was a noted counterpoint teacher and master. I was utterly blown away by his requiem it is the single most haunting piece ever written in the history of music and after I heard it I considered it greater than Mozart's but I place Mozart atop my list only because it has great sentimental value to me and it helped me through a lot of hard times many years ago whereas the Cherubini is a new discovery. Also I must say I wasn't immediately taken by it for whatever reason, I had actually listened to it at first and didn't think too much of it but then days or a week later certain melodies kept creeping into my head haunting me and I said let me listen to this thing again. Upon doing so I became obsessed and listened to it nonstop for 1 month straight all day long every day and concluded that it was indeed the most haunting piece I had ever heard. I thought Mozart's famous Dies Irae was incredible but Cherubini's Dies Irae blew me away and blows the Mozart one away in my opinion. The Cherubini requiem is more of a traditional composition, it features no soloists and is more solemn and in true requiem style unlike the Mozart at times operatic style. Furthermore, at times it sounds like Palestrina-esque motet writing. To this day the Mozart and Cherubini requiems are probably the only two pieces in this world that I cannot really listen to anymore. Only if I am in the proper mood or am feeling depressed to the point of suicidal, they are just too haunting to me and get me into terrifying nihilistic moods that I really do not feel good being in. The Beethoven missa and Brahms Ein Deutches Requiem on the other hand give me the most uplifting feelings I have ever experienced in life and make me feel close to god or the universe or eternity or whatever, whereas the Mozart and Cherubini make me feel close to death and the hideous feelings associated with that. As for other requiems there are many more famous ones, some that are considered to be as good or better than Mozart such as the Verdi, Faure, Berlioz, and a few others but it's not to my liking at all, a little too late romantic for my tastes. p.s. I read somewhere that they played Mozart's requiem at Beethoven's funeral but in another source (I think possibly the Cherubini requiem CD jacket) it says that the Cherubini requiem was played at his funeral. This seems contradictory but seeing as how lengthy the whole ceremony might of been I think it's possible that they were BOTH played at some point. Also, Chopin was quoted as saying he wanted the Mozart requiem played upon his death as well.
December 31, 200520 yr yes I just looked it up to confirm it, several sites say the same: Cherubini's Requiem (1816) was well renowned in the 19th century and performed at Beethoven's funeral. Quite impressing is his "Dies irae" movement. It opens with a striking fanfare, in the following choral parts humble pleading abruptly alternates with freezing terror.
December 31, 200520 yr I would say that among them are Busoni's concerto, Rachmaninoff's 3rd, the Shostakovich 5, and, of his works that have been recorded, Sorabji's Opus Clavicembalisticum, though I believe his great orchestral works like the Jami Symphony (7 hours.....) would be incredible as well.
January 1, 200620 yr The best symphony ever written is Beethoven's Fifth. There is no more universally recognized theme on the planet. As for piano concerti, I personally think Gershwin's Concerto in F is amazing. Greatest opera? Maybe Mozart's Magic Flute. I haven't heard enough opera.
January 1, 200620 yr You kidding? The "greatest" piece of music- Der Ring des Nibelungen! I've not heard it all, but that would certainly earn the title of greatest. As for the best: Beethoven's fifth is the most condensely packed work of genius ever. Mozart's requiem may be the best thing he ever wrote, but I can't call it better than the fifth symphony. The ninth is amazing too, I guess it's kind of hard to decide between them.
January 2, 200620 yr Cliché but true: the "Matthäus Passion" by J.S. Bach. :-) Simply the best and most expressive work ever written. Korneel.
January 2, 200620 yr The best symphony ever written is Beethoven's Fifth. There is no more universally recognized theme on the planet Just because it's recognized, that doesn't mean it's the best: the theme stuck because of the rhythm and mood, that's all. It is, obviously, excelent, as it is Beethoven, but the 9th is by far superior: it was also the most innovative of the time. As for piano concerti, I personally think Gershwin's Concerto in F is amazing It's gorgeous (and yes, amazing) but far from being the greatest: what can you do with Mozart's, Beethoven's and Brahms' concertos hangin' around? Greatest opera? Maybe Mozart's Magic Flute. I haven't heard enough opera That's harder to say: opera can, after all, vary a lot. Here are some recomendations: 1 - Monteverdi's ORFEO 2 - Handel's GIULIO CESARE 3 - Purcell's DIDO AND AENEAS 4 - Mozart's LE NOZZE DI FIGARO 5 - Salieri's AXUR RE D'ORMUS 6 - Mozart's DON GIOVANNI 7 - Beethoven's FIDELIO 8 - Rossini's IL BARBIERE DI SIVIGLIA 9 - Rossini's GUILLAUME TELL 10 - Verdi's NABUCCO 11 - Verdi's LA TRAVIATA 12 - Verdi's RIGOLETTO 13 - Verdi's OTELLO 14 - Verdi's FALSTAFF 15 - Puccini's TOSCA 16 - Puccini's LA BOHÉME 17 - Puccini's MADAME BUTTERFLY 18 - Puccini's TURANDOT 19 - Debussy's PELLEAS ET MELISANDE 20 - Alban Berg's LULU That should keep you rader busy! :blink:
January 3, 200620 yr Ah well here I go:Chamber: Beethoven's Grosse Fuge Piano Concerto: Mozart's 22nd, or Beethoven's 3rd. Maybe even Brahms; 1st. Symphony: Beethoven's 9th, or 4th. Overture: Beethoven's King Stephen Overture, or Egmont..OR Leonore No. 3! Piano Miniatures: All go to Chopin. Maybe some Schumann Violin Concerti: I have no idea. Piano Sonata: Beethoven's Hammerklavier sonata, or Liszt's B minor. give me some other types of pieces hahaa [/b] Finally someone else who really likes Mozart's 22nd!! :)
January 3, 200620 yr M_is_D, I didn't say Gershwin's was the greatest, I simply thought it was amazing. Nico, try the following: + Piano character piece + Orchestral tone poem + Opera + Musical drama (and under this heading, best SONG) + Instrumental solo (example: Debussy's Flute Syrinx) + Waltz for either piano or orchestra And while we're diversifying things, should we add best work by each composer?
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.