June 11, 20205 yr Revised and expanded one of my earlier pieces. The accompaniment sounds rather bland and repetitive. Any tips on that? Thank you
June 11, 20205 yr I love it! Its always a pleasure to hear a new mazurka, and this one is very beautiful and idiomatic. I’m sure it would sound even better with rubato, which might smooth over Measure 15, the only part that sounded slightly unusual to me. I personally didn’t think the accompaniment was too repetitive, but I do wish it was a bit longer. Perhaps you could extend the themes a bit and repeat them, or add something like a scherzando section. That could also allow you to use a different left hand pattern if you like. Nevertheless it’s still a very good mazurka, and I hope you continue writing more of them in the future. Edited June 11, 20205 yr by Fruisen
June 11, 20205 yr I like it! I see what you mean that the left hand is somewhat repetitive but I actually don't think that's too much of an issue for a short piece which seems ideal for a beginner-intermediate level pianist.
June 11, 20205 yr Author 7 hours ago, Fruisen said: I love it! Its always a pleasure to hear a new mazurka, and this one is very beautiful and idiomatic. I’m sure it would sound even better with rubato, which might smooth over Measure 15, the only part that sounded slightly unusual to me. I personally didn’t think the accompaniment was too repetitive, but I do wish it was a bit longer. Perhaps you could extend the themes a bit and repeat them, or add something like a scherzando section. That could also allow you to use a different left hand pattern if you like. Nevertheless it’s still a very good mazurka, and I hope you continue writing more of them in the future. Thank you!
June 11, 20205 yr Very nice work! I agree with @bkho, the left hand is perfectly fine given the difficulty level. (In fact, I think it's rather variated enough to keep it interesting even for more advanced pianists.) My only issue, and I hate to bring this up, is that a mazurka is typically in Lydian mode, and this piece isn't. Difficult to do since it's in a minor key, I know. I don't think its lack of Lydian mode-ness is anything serious, just wanted to bring it to your attention in case you wanted to attempt Lydian mode in future mazurkas!
June 11, 20205 yr Author 1 hour ago, Tónskáld said: Very nice work! I agree with @bkho, the left hand is perfectly fine given the difficulty level. (In fact, I think it's rather variated enough to keep it interesting even for more advanced pianists.) My only issue, and I hate to bring this up, is that a mazurka is typically in Lydian mode, and this piece isn't. Difficult to do since it's in a minor key, I know. I don't think its lack of Lydian mode-ness is anything serious, just wanted to bring it to your attention in case you wanted to attempt Lydian mode in future mazurkas! Thank you! Hmm. I see what you mean my the mode.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.